Butterscotch Cottage

9474 West Lake Road

Contact: Push2Chat

Check Availability

initMessage('0',''); initButtonMessage('Select Arrival');
<< <
 > >>
May 2017
June 2017
      Unavailable online (Call for availability)
      Available for Arrival Only
      Available for Departure Only
      User Selected Dates for Reservation
Directions: Click on the calendar to select your arrival and departure dates. Then calculate your rental cost and book it!
 Arrival    Departure   Promo Code (Optional)
Reset Dates
Compare Property View Comparisons Virtual Tours

Home Overview

Keuka Lake
Max Occ:
Full Baths:
Half Baths:
Check-in Day:

Property Details

Vehicle Parking:
Stairs to Property:
Slope of Lot:
Stairs to Beach:
Lake Frontage:
70 ft. Breakwall
Yes (6x80) (Perm.)
Nearest Launch:
Hammondsport (2.5 mi)
Water Source:
Septic Tank

Keuka (Native American for: Canoe Landing)

Keuka Lake is called the "Lady of the Lakes" because of its amazing beauty. The Indian name Keuka means "canoe landing," but this Finger Lakes area used to be called Crooked Lake by the early settlers. It is very unique among the Finger Lakes because it features a scenic bluff over seven hundred feet above the lake, and is the only Finger Lake that outlets into another Lake. Keuka Lake is roughly 20 miles long and varies in width all the way up to 2 miles.

Terms and Conditions

Note: Rates shown are the rental amount only. Click here for full details on rates, reservation fees, and payment policies

Note: Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in description. Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets. Air conditioning is not provided unless it is explicitly stated under the property’s amenities.

This property information, though deemed accurate is not guaranteed. Properties, features and attributes are subject to change or withdrawal without notice.


Guest Reviews

Average Rating: 5.0

View All Submit Review
Douglas, Rochester NY 07/07/2012
Show/Hide Review


Better Than Ever!

Dates: 01/01/2017 - 06/15/2017 Coming for 2017 Season! Butterscotch Cottage is adding a sunroom off the bedroom annex, and an extended deck over the lakeside of the house. Guests will now be able to enjoy the lake atmosphere and fabulous views in any weather!


Come to Butterscotch Cottage and your lakeside vacation will be a breeze! Once a historic barn, this Keuka Lake cottage has been completely renovated into a quality residence, blending country charm with modern ease and convenience.

The main entry is open and airy featuring a living, dining and kitchen area, as well as a full bath. The comfortable living room overlooks the lake and offers plenty of relaxation space, as well as a flat screen TV/DVD/Blu-Ray combo for the occasional rainy day. A fully equipped country-style kitchen offers ample cupboard space and room to prepare all your meals, and the dining area provides beautiful lake views. The spacious full bath on this floor includes shower, tub, and laundry facilities.

Just off the living/dining room is a deck that leads to a detached living annex with central air, which consists of a foyer and two connecting bedrooms. This annex is completely separate from the main residence, and features a separate entry door from the parking area. One bedroom overlooks the lake and contains a queen-size bed and cable TV. The other contains a twin bed and trundle bed, ideal for children or late risers. Both bedrooms and the foyer offer ample storage space for clothing, allowing you to unpack, relax, and enjoy.

Just up the L-shaped staircase off the living room is a spacious, air-conditioned master bedroom, featuring a king-size bed, dresser and closet space, cable TV with DVD player, and nice views of the dock and lakefront. A sitting area allows you to relax in privacy, while a separate exterior entrance from the parking area enables you to come and go as you please. A half door at the base of the stairs in the living room prevents little ones from climbing the stairwell, and offers a mostly private retreat away from the main living areas.

The lower level features a cozy family room and attractive kitchenette. The small kitchenette contains a coffee maker, sink, microwave, and small refrigerator. The family room offers comfortable seating along with a gas fireplace and cable TV/DVD/VHS combo. A sliding glass door leads to a furnished patio and access to the terraced lawns and waterfront. A fourth bedroom with a full size bed and a separate full bath with shower, complete the lower level.

Butterscotch Cottage provides a number of outdoor venues. The main floor’s lake view deck is a great location for morning coffee or evening dessert, while the patio and lawn with spacious picnic table and large charcoal grill, is an ideal space for all guests to cook and eat together. A deck over the boat house offers panoramic lake views too! A picnic table and lounge chairs on the dock offer plenty of seating space for outdoor snacks and sun bathing.

The lakefront is mostly breakwall, with a set of stairs at the entry that lead into the water. Boat whips are provided on the dock for mooring your boat throughout your vacation at Butterscotch Cottage. Located in the "Coolest Small Town in America," Hammondsport, NY, this charming home is just a few minutes from the village and Bully Hill/Dr. Franks Wineries.


  • Fireplace
  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Dishwasher
  • Linens Provided
  • Internet Access
  • DVD Player
  • TV
  • VCR
  • Firepit
  • BBQ - Charcoal
  • Cable
  • Central Air in Annex, Wall Unit in Living Room on Main Level, Portable Air Conditioning Unit in 2nd Level Bedroom
  • Wine Fridge with Red/White Temp. Controls
  • HDTV in Living Room
  • Boat Whips
  • 40 ft. to Beach
  • 9 ft. Deep at End of Dock
  • Deck over Boathouse
  • Partially Covered Porch
  • Fireplace is Gas
  • Ceiling Fans in Most Rooms
  • Bedroom 1, Loft - 1 King
  • Bedroom 2, Lower Level - 1 Double
  • Bedroom 3, Annex - 1 Queen
  • Bedroom 4, Annex - 2 Singles (Trundle)
  • Bathroom 1, First Floor - Full - Shower/Tub combo
  • Bathroom 2, Lower Level - Full - Shower only

Request More Information

Feedback Form