On The Rocks

374 East Lake Rd.

Contact: Push2Chat

Check Availability

initMessage('0',''); initButtonMessage('Select Arrival');
<< <
 > >>
May 2017
June 2017
      Unavailable online (Call for availability)
      Available for Arrival Only
      Available for Departure Only
      User Selected Dates for Reservation
Directions: Click on the calendar to select your arrival and departure dates. Then calculate your rental cost and book it!
 Arrival    Departure   Promo Code (Optional)
Reset Dates
Compare Property View Comparisons Virtual Tours

Home Overview

Keuka Lake
Max Occ:
Full Baths:
Half Baths:
Check-in Day:

Property Details

Vehicle Parking:
4 Including trailers
Stairs to Property:
Slope of Lot:
Stairs to Beach:
Lake Frontage:
140 ft. Natural
Boat Lift:
Manual Up to 3500 lb. / 21 ft.
Mooring Bouy:
Nearest Launch:
Morgan Marine (3 mi.)
Water Source:
Window A/C Unit

Keuka (Native American for: Canoe Landing)

Keuka Lake is called the "Lady of the Lakes" because of its amazing beauty. The Indian name Keuka means "canoe landing," but this Finger Lakes area used to be called Crooked Lake by the early settlers. It is very unique among the Finger Lakes because it features a scenic bluff over seven hundred feet above the lake, and is the only Finger Lake that outlets into another Lake. Keuka Lake is roughly 20 miles long and varies in width all the way up to 2 miles.

Terms and Conditions

Note: Rates shown are the rental amount only. Click here for full details on rates, reservation fees, and payment policies

Note: Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in description. Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets. Air conditioning is not provided unless it is explicitly stated under the property’s amenities.

This property information, though deemed accurate is not guaranteed. Properties, features and attributes are subject to change or withdrawal without notice.


Guest Reviews

Average Rating: 4.7

View All Submit Review
Bost 08/14/2016
Show/Hide Review
Kenyon, East Amherst NY 07/11/2015
Show/Hide Review
Sam, Horseheads NY 06/25/2016
Show/Hide Review


A truly unique blend of traditional lake house and contemporary updates, the ideal lakeside vacation is well within your reach. This cozy, 3 bedroom family-style cottage with one hundred and forty feet of beautiful, gradual entry lake frontage is waiting for you!

Just a quick, 10 minute drive from Penn Yan and conveniently located less than 3 miles from Morgan Marine on the east side of Keuka Lake, On The Rocks may be the perfect small group vacation rental. Plenty of level parking, enough for up to 4 vehicles and trailers, is on the highest of the three tiers of the property's lot. Just a few yards away, through the charming wooden arbor spanning the walkway and down a handful of steps you will find a block patio sitting area and propane barbecue grill, right next to the home’s main entrance. As you enter, you will notice the level plank walkway along the side of the home, with an enticing glimpse of one corner of the large deck that wraps around the front of the home. Access to the basement garage/boathouse, which also houses the laundry area and the second full size refrigerator/freezer, is found at the bottom of just a few steps at the corner of the deck.

Step directly into the main living area to find a brand new half bath to your left, conveniently located just inside the door. As you enter, it is impossible to ignore the view offered by beautiful oversized thermal pane windows looking toward the south, allowing in plenty of natural light and making it easy to enjoy that book you’ve been meaning to get to while lounging on the comfy, over-stuffed furniture. The beautifully carved fireplace mantle, framing the wood burning brick fireplace, still remains, giving the room a cozy feel.

To the rear of the living room a dining area adjoins, complete with large family-style table and plenty of seating for the entire group of eight. Take one step up and to the left and enter the adorable, galley-style kitchen with bright, overhead lighting and additional light from a window over the double-bowl sink. The full bath, equipped with a stand-up shower stall, will be found directly off the kitchen.

Continue through the kitchen to access the home’s bedrooms. You will be delighted to see that each bedroom also affords breathtaking views of the area through more, recently updated large windows that will allow you to let in a cool, fresh breeze from the lake if you wish.

The first bedroom, directly across from the kitchen, offers a queen bed. To the left, the second bedroom, also furnished with a queen, has sliding patio doors, allowing the guests occupying this room direct, private access to the wrap-around deck. The third bedroom, across the hall from the other two, is equipped with two sets of twin bunk beds, perfect for the children in the group!

Spend the afternoon in the shade provided by large, mature trees over a free-standing deck at the edge of the yard. Sun worshipers will enjoy a large deck overlooking the lake that provides plenty of space for soaking up the afternoon sunshine, watching the children swim and play in the water, or preparing the day’s catch for the barbecue. For those that prefer lounging closer to the water, just head down a few steps directly from the deck, sit and sway gently with the waterfront breezes in the wooden swing, or park your favorite lounger on the dock or the level, shale waterfront. From the beach, guests can also easily access the laundry area and second refrigerator located in the garage basement/boathouse, also convenient for storing beach toys and belongings when not in use. A seasonal dock with a boat hoist is available for guest enjoyment as well.

Note: Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in description. Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets.


  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Linens Provided
  • Internet Access
  • Non-motorized Watercraft Provided
  • DVD Player
  • TV
  • Firepit
  • BBQ - Propane
  • Cable
  • Window A/C Unit
  • Window A/C Units in Bedrooms 1, 3, and Living Room
  • Canoe
  • Paddle Boat
  • Bedroom 1, Main Level - 1 Queen
  • Bedroom 2, Main Level - 1 Queen
  • Bedroom 3, Main Level - 2 Bunkbed Sets (4 Twin)
  • Bathroom 1, Main Level - Full - Shower only
  • Bathroom 2, Main Level - Half
  • Fireplace is Decorative Only

Request More Information

Feedback Form