By Erin from Wellsboro, Pennsylvania , Stay: 07/02/2017 - 07/09/2017
July 2017 Stay
We just wrapped up a week at this rental and loved it! The home was well appointed with everything we needed and was in a great location between Hammondsport and Penn Yan and close to some new wineries and breweries as well. Our only disappointment was that the water was not turned on in the boat house for use of the restroom or sink. I would definitely recommend this home!
By Elizabeth from Mooresville, North Carolina , Stay: 07/02/2023 - 07/09/2023
This home was great for our annual vacation to Keuka Lake! The home was very clean upon our arrival and access the house was very easy. Although the bedrooms are on the small side, the house is very spacious and has a great deck on the front of the house with an incredible view of the bluff and the lake! The kitchen is huge and well-stocked with cooking utensils, etc. and made it very easy to prepare large meals for our family. We used the gas grill several nights and it worked ok - it seemed to take a long time to get hot. The waterfront area/dock is huge and has a little "house/shed" type of structure with a refrigerator, sink, microwave, and plenty of counter space. My 10-year-old stepson played in this house as he made it into his "restaurant/snack bar", where he served us drinks and snacks while we enjoyed the dock and water throughout the week. This area also has a covered area, where some of our family were able to sit in the shade at a picnic table, but still be outside with everyone to enjoy the lake. Something to note, however; if you have elderly family/friends with you: the short walk down to the waterfront is a grassy incline without stairs or steps. There are also 2 small sets of stairs to walk up to access the house. Overall, we had plenty of space to spend another great week at Keuka!
By Debra from Horseheads, New York , Stay: 07/09/2023 - 07/16/2023
This is the third year renting from premier properties and definitely will be using them again next year!!
By Angela from Manlius, New York , Stay: 06/15/2023 - 06/19/2023
We loved the house. The dock was amazing with the small boat house complete with half bath. It made it so convenient. It is a beautiful location. The home is very cozy and comfortable. And they back yard, where the hot tub is, feels very private which is nice. Overall, we had a great experience.
By Jennifer from Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, Stay: 09/16/2022 - 09/19/2022
Our group of high school friends decided to spend our 30th reunion on Keuka Lake! This house was perfect - enough beds, 2 full bathrooms- which you need with 6 women! The hot tub was great for a night of relaxing after a few wineries. But our favorite spot was the dock and firepit- with a great additional dock house. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay!!
By Bonnie from Collins, New York, Stay: 05/05/2023 - 05/08/2023
The home was relaxing and had breathtaking views of Keuka Lake. We really enjoyed our total stay at this home
Thank you for the 5 star rating. We are pleased that you enjoyed your stay and we hope to see you again soon.
- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 05/26/2023
By Bill from Hornell, New York, Stay: 06/06/2021 - 06/12/2021
Wonderful setting and great spaces
Always a sunny or shady spot at the house or boathouse and deck. Spacious kitchen, dining and living rooms. Incredible view!
By Edward G from Pompton Plains, New Jersey, Stay: 08/23/2020 - 08/30/2020
This was our fourth time at simple irresistible and it lived up to it's name. If this property goes on sale please contact me.
By Ronald W from Liberty, Pennsylvania, Stay: 08/02/2020 - 08/09/2020
Spectacular Views and Modern Design Await You!
Great lake location!
By Saralicia H,
August 2019 Stay
We enjoyed our stay very much, the house was great and the lake pier area was amazing.
By Abby R,
August 2019 Stay
Great property, really great location. Comfortable, clean, great lake views.
By Ken L from Laporte, PA,
July 2019 Stay
This is the second year in a row I have rented this property and it is a great place for a vacation. I particularly like the waterfront set up,hot tub and views of the lake from the great room. The property is very family friendly.
By Ken L from Laporte, PA, Stay: 07/01/2018 - 07/07/2018
This is one of the best properties I have ever rented and all of us had a great time.
By Robert C from Penn Yan, NY, Stay: 06/08/2018 - 06/14/2018
June 2018 Stay
We enjoyed the property very much. Beautiful home with a great, central location. Highly recommend this property for comfort and value.
By Cheryl from Clear Spring MD,
This was our first time in the area. We had a great time and will definitely be back. Loved the home we were in and Keuka lake. Thanks so much for helping to make our vacation great!
By Maureen from Pittsburgh PA,
We loved the property - it had plenty of space, beautiful views, and everything we needed for a wonderful long weekend. I truly appreciated the personalized card to wish me well in the Wineglass Half Marathon, as well - such a special touch really meant a lot. We'd love to visit this property again in the future.
By Cathryn from Rochester NY,
Simply Irresistible was no less than amazing. The house was very clean and big! We had wonderful weather therefore the boat house and dock where great! I could not be happier with our stay. Thank you for everything :)
By Joe from Chagrin Falls OH,
Beautiful property, well-maintained. Would stay there again if we return to the Finger Lakes.