Keuka Lake Vacation Rentals

Discover Keuka Lake Vacation Rentals

Keuka Lake is a haven of scenic views, top wineries, and outdoor fun, making it a prime destination for vacation rentals in Keuka Lake, NY. Experience the serenity and excitement that await you.

Why Book with Us?

Discover your ideal Keuka Lake vacation rental with Finger Lakes Premier Properties. From scenic views to top wineries, our properties put you in the heart of it all. And you can enjoy special savings and a variety of activities, from boating to hiking.

Dive into Keuka Lake's Unforgettable Attractions

Vacation rentals in Keuka Lake offer more than just scenic beauty. From state parks and wineries to farmers' markets and museums, there's something for every adventurer, foodie, or history buff. Explore all the attractions and experiences Keuka Lake has to offer.

Don't Miss These Upcoming Events!

The Finger Lakes Region is always buzzing. From wine festivals to family-friendly events, there's something for everyone. Make your trip unforgettable by checking our current events page for more information.

Your Ultimate Guide to Things to Do

Keuka Lake is a year-round playground for outdoor enthusiasts. There's never a dull moment, from watersports and hiking to gourmet dining and live shows. These activities make Keuka Lake vacation properties a top choice. Explore things to do in the area.

Experience Keuka Lake's Unique Allure

Keuka's distinct Y-shape offers a sprawling shoreline that's a paradise for water lovers. Coupled with a vibrant wine culture, it's a sanctuary for both relaxation and adventure. Ready to dive in? Search available properties in Keuka Lake and start planning your vacation today!


Properties Available 93 properties available
Tranquility on Keuka is being renovated for the 2025 rental season.  The description below describes the experience guests will have and the amenities provided.  Please stay tuned for photo updates as the property is completed which is expected to be by April 2025.This property is located on East Lake Road, five miles north of Hammondspor
Tranquility on Keuka
Tranquility on Keuka 2
Tranquility on Keuka 3
Tranquility on Keuka 4
Tranquility on Keuka 5
Prev
Next
Tranquility on Keuka
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 8 guests
Relaxing on the uniquely private and spacious covered deck while immersing yourself in the sights and sounds of Keuka Lake, Bluffing Around is the perfect place to get away and rejuvenate. This spacious home features three bedrooms, one and a half baths, and is just minutes from the small quaint town of Penn Yan and nearby Keuka College. Whether yo
Bluffing Around
Bluffing Around 2
Bluffing Around 3
Bluffing Around 4
Bluffing Around 5
Prev
Next
Bluffing Around
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 10 guests
With great space for relaxing lake living, both inside and out, and a location near many local hotspots of adventure, Edgewater Escape is ready to accommodate for the tastes and needs of any and all beach-goers!Descend the stairs from the road to this bright and airy classic beach side home and you will immediately be lakeside.  From the momen
Edgewater Escape
Edgewater Escape 2
Edgewater Escape 3
Edgewater Escape 4
Edgewater Escape 5
Prev
Next
Edgewater Escape
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 6 guests
This charming year round, lakeside cottage is just boasting with recently remodeled furnishings and was featured on HGTV's Lakefront Bargain Hunt. Located minutes from downtown Penn Yan where you will find local favorites like the Seneca Farms Ice Cream, Laurentide Brewing and only a few miles from Crispin Hill Wedding Venue and Aband
Willow Tree Cottage
Willow Tree Cottage 2
Willow Tree Cottage 3
Willow Tree Cottage 4
Willow Tree Cottage 5
Prev
Next
Willow Tree Cottage
Keuka Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 8 guests
Nestled on the north west tip of ‘Y’ shaped Keuka Lake, Lady of the Lakes Suites 4 is one of a 5 apartment lodging facility, perfect for couples or small families. Inquiries can be made to rent all five units for small weddings, family reunions or area events.Beautifully decorated with a "Flight Over Keuka" theme, the color sc
Lady of the Lakes Suites 4
Lady of the Lakes Suites 4 2
Lady of the Lakes Suites 4 3
Lady of the Lakes Suites 4 4
Lady of the Lakes Suites 4 5
Prev
Next
Lady of the Lakes Suites 4
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 4 guests
Afternoon Paradise offers guests the opportunity to experience old-world estate living at the lake. Located on a quiet private drive, this beautiful estate home with guest cottage is nestled on 4 acres at the water's edge.If you're at the lake to enjoy the water, the lakefront patio is a great place to sunbathe, tie your lures, eat a casual
BOOK FOR 2 NIGHTS! BOOK FOR 2 NIGHTS!
BOOK FOR 2 NIGHTS!
This home is available for a 2-night stay August 24th - September 9th!
Afternoon Paradise
Afternoon Paradise 2
Afternoon Paradise 3
Afternoon Paradise 4
Afternoon Paradise 5
Prev
Next
Afternoon Paradise
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 8 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 5 Full baths
Guests 18 guests
This charming, two-story lakeside cottage is located on the West Bluff of beautiful Keuka Lake. Bluestone Cottage offers beautiful sunsets and fantastic lake views for your enjoyment and relaxation.As you walk down to the first landing, you will enter the second level where all the bedrooms and full bath are located. The first bedroom is painted li
Bluestone Cottage
Bluestone Cottage 2
Bluestone Cottage 3
Bluestone Cottage 4
Bluestone Cottage 5
Prev
Next
Bluestone Cottage
Keuka Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 8 guests
Nested just south of the Basin Marina, The Kove is the perfect Keuka Lake retreat! This 4-bedroom, 3 bath home is an ideal Finger Lakes getaway for friends and family to gather under one roof. Ample wineries, wedding event centers and the Keuka Lake State Park are all just minutes away.Inside, knotty pine accents can be discovered throughout this l
The Kove
The Kove 2
The Kove 3
The Kove 4
The Kove 5
Prev
Next
The Kove
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Guests 12 guests
Come and have some ‘Fun in the Sun’ during your next vacation! This beautifully maintained lake house is within walking distance to Penn Yan, Red Jacket Park & Playground, and Morgan’s Marine!The main entry from the parking area leads into the living area, which features an open floor plan for easy entertaining with the entire
Fun in the Sun
Fun in the Sun 2
Fun in the Sun 3
Fun in the Sun 4
Fun in the Sun 5
Prev
Next
Fun in the Sun
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 8 guests
With 2 bedrooms and a spacious sleeping loft, exquisite lake views aren’t all that will awe you when you stay at Just Bluffin’!  Sleeping eight guests comfortably, this home is located minutes from downtown Penn Yan, Keuka College and several Keuka Lake Wine Trail favorites.  Just Bluffin’ is the quintessential dream hom
Just Bluffin'
Just Bluffin' 2
Just Bluffin' 3
Just Bluffin' 4
Just Bluffin' 5
Prev
Next
Just Bluffin'
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 8 guests
Location, location, location! This small one bedroom cottage with a converted basement is on prime, gorgeous, Keuka lakeside real estate. With over 135 feet of frontage, there is gradual shale beach for wading, a large lakeside lawn for a game of tag and a boat slip and break wall for swimming. On the 2nd level there is a small kitchen, small livin
Willow Point
Willow Point 2
Willow Point 3
Willow Point 4
Willow Point 5
Prev
Next
Willow Point
Keuka Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 4 guests
Nestled on the north west tip of ‘Y’ shaped Keuka Lake, Lady of the Lakes Suites is a 5 apartment lodging facility, perfect for couples or small families. Inquiries can be made to rent all five units for small weddings, family reunions or area events.Beautifully decorated, each suite has its own theme that’s sure to relax you
Lady of the Lakes Suites for Groups
Lady of the Lakes Suites for Groups 2
Lady of the Lakes Suites for Groups 3
Lady of the Lakes Suites for Groups 4
Lady of the Lakes Suites for Groups 5
Prev
Next
Lady of the Lakes Suites for Groups
Keuka Lake
Bedrooms 10 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 5 Full baths
Guests 20 guests

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree

Copyright © 2024 • Finger Lakes Premier Properties

All Rights Reserved.