Discover Our Newest Lakefront Vacation Rentals in the Finger Lakes!

We're constantly adding stunning new lakefront homes to our exclusive vacation rental collection—each offering a unique way to experience the beauty of the Finger Lakes. Whether you're planning a cozy winter getaway, a sun-soaked summer escape, or a colorful fall retreat, there's always something new to explore.

Be the first to stay in our newly listed vacation homes
Enjoy private lakefront access and breathtaking views
Experience the comfort, tranquility, and charm of a professionally managed Finger Lakes rental

Make sure to check back often—new properties and open dates are added regularly. Your next unforgettable Finger Lakes vacation starts here!

20 properties available

Location, location, location! Among the rolling hills just north of downtown Watkins Glen and tucked between the tree line, you’ll find the charming: Watkin’ Lakeside. A spectacular and peaceful setting, this home has everything you’ll need and more for a quintessential Finger Lakes getaway. Located one mile from

Escape to A Wave From it All and treat yourself to a large dose modern charm on your next Finger Lakes vacation! Perfect for guests of any age, this beautifully decorated home is ideal for your next family reunion or couple’s retreat. Conveniently located right next to the Olney Place on Keuka Lake, you’ll appreciate their s

Welcome to Pond Cottage – Your peaceful escape in the heart of the Finger Lakes! Nestled just minutes from the sparkling shores of Keuka Lake, Pond Cottage offers a private and serene getaway surrounded by the natural beauty of New York’s Finger Lakes Wine Country. You’ll be perfectly positioned to explore the region’s

Welcome to My Blue Heaven, a stunning lakeside escape nestled along the tranquil shores of Cayuga Lake. Perfectly designed for both a couples retreat or a family getaway, My Blue Heaven is the ideal Finger Lakes Getaway!Enter into the open living area. This modern retreat boasts a beautifully designed interior with a soothing palette of

Located on the west side of Canandaigua Lake, Belle Maison is the perfect "Beautiful Home" to experience a luxury getaway! An abundance of Finger Lakes favorites are available right at your fingertips whether you’re attending a wedding at the New York Kitchen, tasting local brews along Kershaw Park or skiing down Bristol Mount

Welcome to Dreamways, a stunning lakeside retreat on the shores of Keuka Lake. Designed for both relaxation and luxury, this spacious four-bedroom home offers breathtaking views, modern amenities, and direct lake access for the ultimate Finger Lakes getaway.Step inside to find a beautifully designed interior, featuring a stunning kitchen with white

Create timeless memories at Hidden House! Located midway down the west side of Canandaigua Lake, this custom-built cedar sided home offers 124 foot of prime lake living. With ample opportunity for both relaxation and fun, this three bedroom, two bath home is perfect for your next Finger Lakes vacation.A U-shaped driveway greets you with

Whether you’re attending a wedding or graduation at Ithaca College or Cornell University, or coming into town for a Cayuga Lake wine tour, fall foliage, or our many local parks, you’ll be in complete serenity at Osprey Landing. Located on the southeast side of the lake less than ten minutes from Ithaca; there’s ample opportu

With a name that says it all, “Honeoye Happy Place” will capture your heart and have your family craving another lake adventure before you even get back home! Located on Honeoye Lake, one of the Finger Lakes western most lakes, this home is perfect for a couples or small family retreat whether you're frequenting local hiking d

Lake peeping views and prime location welcome you to Seneca Lake when you stay at Lower Lake Retreat. Centrally located between Watkins Glen and Geneva, you’ll find this three-bedroom home nestled into the east side of Seneca Lake.Upon entering this cozy home, the kitchen happily greets you. The open galley kitchen allows the chef in yo

Minutes away from downtown Hammondsport, and a short drive north to the Village of Penn Yan, Gimme Shelter boasts; location, location, location! This four-bedroom luxury home has much to offer and makes an ideal Finger Lakes getaway for guests of all ages. Leave all your cares at home and enjoy taking shelter at the lake!Inside, views o

Captivating unforgettable views of Canandaigua Lake; Sunset Hideaway will sweep you off your feet. An ideal couples retreat, this peaceful home is located among the rolling hillside of Canandaigua Lake. Each night at sunset, you’ll quickly see how this unique destination got its name; making this a Finger Lakes getaway you’r

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

First Name

Last Name

Phone Number

Email Address

Comments

I agree By filling out this form you are agreeing to receive future information and newsletters regarding Finger Lakes real estate listings, rental properties and trends. Your information will be kept confidential and only used by Finger Lakes Premier Properties. You can unsubscribe at anytime.