Discover Our Newest Lakefront Vacation Rentals in the Finger Lakes!
We're constantly adding stunning new lakefront homes to our exclusive vacation rental collection—each offering a unique way to experience the beauty of the Finger Lakes. Whether you're planning a cozy winter getaway, a sun-soaked summer escape, or a colorful fall retreat, there's always something new to explore.
- Be the first to stay in our newly listed vacation homes
- Enjoy private lakefront access and breathtaking views
- Experience the comfort, tranquility, and charm of a professionally managed Finger Lakes rental
Make sure to check back often—new properties and open dates are added regularly. Your next unforgettable Finger Lakes vacation starts here!

18 properties available
Welcome to Pond Cottage – Your peaceful escape in the heart of the Finger Lakes! Nestled just minutes from the sparkling shores of Keuka Lake, Pond Cottage offers a private and serene getaway surrounded by the natural beauty of New York’s Finger Lakes Wine Country. You’ll be perfectly positioned to explore the region’s
Pond Cottage
Keuka Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
6
guests
Welcome to The Overlook on Canandaigua Lake, a stunning Finger Lakes retreat perched high above the sparkling waters of Canandaigua Lake. Surrounded by mature trees and peaceful natural beauty, this private four-bedroom getaway offers breathtaking panoramic lake views, comfortable accommodations, and all the amenities needed for a relaxing escape.&
The Overlook
Canandaigua Lake
4
bedrooms
3
Full baths
12
guests
Welcome to Eagle’s Landing, a year-round, peaceful Finger Lakes retreat surrounded by more than 20 acres of private, wooded beauty in the Keuka Lake region. Tucked among the trees with beautiful lake views, this inviting three-bedroom home offers comfortable accommodations for up to six guests, a private hot tub, and plenty of space to relax,
Eagle's Landing
Keuka Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
1
Half baths
6
guests
*NEW 4-Person Hot Tub Available* Welcome to your perfect Quack of Dawn, a charming pet-friendly waterfront retreat offering breathtaking lake views, direct water access, and all the comforts of home. Ideal for couples, small families, or friends traveling together, this 2-bedroom, 2-bath vacation home comfortably accommodates up to 4 guests and pro
Quack of Dawn
Seneca Lake
2
bedrooms
2
Full baths
4
guests
Nestled along the shores of Keuka Lake, this remarkable timber-frame estate redefines waterfront living with a blend of elegance, comfort, and breathtaking scenery. Set on a sweeping acre of manicured lawn, Good Times invites guests into a world where modern indulgence meets timeless craftsmanship.Bathed in natural light and framed by soaring windo
Good Times
Keuka Lake
5
bedrooms
5
Full baths
16
guests
Set along 50 feet of pristine Canandaigua Lake frontage, Shep’s Lake House is a welcoming family home designed with togetherness in mind—ideal for families and groups looking to slow down and enjoy lake life. Located on a quiet, residential road just south of the City of Canandaigua, the setting offers a peaceful retreat while still bei
Shep's Lake House
Canandaigua Lake
5
bedrooms
3
Full baths
10
guests
Nestled along the scenic western shore of Canandaigua Lake, Coach-ella on the Lake places you right in the heart of the Finger Lakes experience! Wake up to peaceful lake views and unwind in this bright, beautifully designed 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home built in 2025—perfect for a relaxing couples retreat. After parking, you’ll head u
Coach-ella on the Lake
Canandaigua Lake
2
bedrooms
2
Full baths
4
guests
Welcome to West Lake Reserve, Canandaigua Lake's newest luxury custom home and one of the Finger Lakes' most extraordinary private vacation rentals. Brand new and never before offered as a vacation home, this stunning lakefront estate combines timeless architecture, sophisticated design, and breathtaking waterfront views to create an unforg
West Lake Reserve
Canandaigua Lake
6
bedrooms
5
Full baths
12
guests
Welcome to Hearthstone House, a charming historic lakefront retreat just minutes from downtown Canandaigua, in the heart of New York’s beautiful Finger Lakes region.Built in 1835, this one-of-a-kind lake house pairs the warmth and character of a classic farmhouse with the comforts and conveniences of a modern vacation home. With four bedrooms
Hearthstone
Canandaigua Lake
4
bedrooms
3
Full baths
1
Half baths
10
guests
Escape to the rustic beauty of the Finger Lakes at Cedar & Stone, a charming timber-frame getaway nestled among the rolling hills just minutes from Keuka Lake and the heart of Hammondsport. Blending the warmth of a classic log cabin with modern comforts and upscale amenities, this inviting vacation home offers the perfect setting for couples, f
Cedar & Stone
Keuka Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
6
guests
Sunny naps on the shore, cool misty mornings on the deck, and lazy Sunday afternoons with the family in a quiet place all your own—Serenity Point is the secluded lake getaway you’ve been looking for. This breezy, tranquil 3-bedroom, 2-bath home sits just steps from the shoreline and showcases breathtaking views of Seneca Lake.As soon as
Serenity Point
Seneca Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
6
guests
Perched high above the eastern shore of Seneca Lake, Seneca Vista offers breathtaking panoramic views of the lake, rolling vineyard-covered hillsides, and some of the most spectacular sunsets in the Finger Lakes. Whether you're planning a family vacation, a couples' getaway, or a wine country retreat with friends, this spacious five-bedroom
Seneca Vista
Seneca Lake
5
bedrooms
3
Full baths
14
guests
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Finger Lakes Premier Properties
All Rights Reserved.