Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals

Uncover the Charms of Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals in New York

Cayuga Lake is a treasure trove of natural beauty, cultural landmarks, and aquatic adventures. It's a sought-after locale for Cayuga Lake vacation rentals, where the blend of relaxation and thrill is unparalleled. All of our Cayuga Lake vacation rentals have amazing views and lakefront access.

Why Choose Our Rentals?

Discover your dream Cayuga Lake vacation rental with Finger Lakes Premier Properties. From cozy cottages to luxury estates, we offer special savings and top-notch service for an unforgettable lakeside experience.

Explore Cayuga Lake's Must-See Spots

Staying in vacation rentals on Cayuga Lake, NY, isn't just about the lake views. The area boasts attractions like the Cayuga Wine Trail and the Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge, catering to wine connoisseurs and wildlife enthusiasts alike. Delve into the diverse experiences Cayuga Lake has in store.

Hang out with the Locals at Exciting Events

The Finger Lakes area is a hub of activity. There's an event for every interest, from the Ithaca Festival to boating regattas. For an in-depth list of upcoming events, visit our current events page.

Activities Galore at Cayuga Lake

Cayuga Lake is a paradise for those who crave outdoor excitement. The options are endless, whether it's paddleboarding, exploring the local farmers' markets, or enjoying a lakeside picnic. These offerings make Cayuga Lake vacation rentals a top pick for a fulfilling vacation. Discover more things to do in the area.

Discover Cayuga Lake's Distinctive Appeal

Cayuga Lake's elongated shape provides ample shoreline for water activities and is one of the best lakes to fish in. At the same time, its proximity to educational institutions like Cornell University adds a unique cultural flair. Eager to experience it all? Our largest Cayuga Lake property, Glenwood Lodge, is a beautiful colonial home with over 30 acres of untouched beauty and can sleep up to 20 people. Browse available properties in Cayuga Lake and kickstart your dream vacation now!


Properties Available 45 properties available
Located only half a mile from Sheldrake Point Winery and 15 minutes from Taughannock Falls State Park you’ll find tranquil; Lakeview Landing. This beautiful lake home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 1/2 baths for all of your family and friends to gather comfortably.Through the entrance you’ll be greeted with stairs leading both up and down this
Hot HOT 40
Lakeview Landing
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 8 guests
Located on the west side of Cayuga Lake, and right in the heart of the Finger Lakes; this charming hillside home have you wishing you took a moment to retreat to the lake sooner.  Whether you travel north to downtown Seneca Falls, or south to the City of Ithaca, adventures and Finger Lakes fun surround you when you stay at Wolffy’s House
Hot HOT 31
Wolffy's House on the Hill
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 9 guests
Blue Heron Shores Estate rents as a property accommodating 18 guests from May 1 - October 31.  In the winter months, enjoy a nice winter getaway at Blue Heron Shores (renting without the guest house) for guests up to an occupancy of 12.Filled with luxury and pristine views, Blue Heron Shores Estate will charm your next Finger Lakes vacation!&n
Hot HOT 43
Blue Heron Shores Estate
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 4 Full baths
Guests 18 guests
Vacation in this contemporary lakeside cottage on the west side of beautiful Cayuga Lake. Situated within walking distance of Liquid State Brewing - North Shore, Toro Winery, and only 2 miles from the Deans Cove Marina. Enjoy a hike at the nearby nature trail offering 1 mile of hiking or biking trails. The Duck-In offers everything you need for tha
Hot HOT 32
The Duck-In
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Guests 10 guests
Located on the eastern side of the Finger Lakes, "Dash of Lake Life" is the perfect Cayuga Lake getaway!  Day trips to Ithaca and Taughannock Falls State Park, the quaint town of Seneca Falls and an abundance of Finger Lakes favorites are right at your fingertips.Entering the great room, the exquisite A-frame structure is decora
Hot HOT 45
Dash of Lake Life
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 12 guests
Blue Heron Shores rents as a property accommodating 12 guests from November 1 - April 30.  Beginning May 1 through October 31, enjoy a reservation at Blue Heron Shores Estate and accommodate guests up to an occupancy of 18 with an added guest house!Filled with luxury and pristine views, Blue Heron Shores will charm your next Finger Lakes vacat
Hot HOT 20
Blue Heron Shores
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Guests 12 guests
Treat your family to a Cayuga Lake retreat at LongView on the Cove.  Located in the heart of the Finger Lakes, midway between Seneca Falls and Ithaca ample adventures and fun await you.Recently remodeled, this five-bedroom home is boasting with panoramic lake views and all the comforts of home.  Inside, custom built cabinetry hug the kitc
Hot HOT 35
LongView on the Cove
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 10 guests
Centrally located between Ithaca, Watkins Glen, and Geneva in the beautiful Sheldrake Point area, you’ll find this recently renovated cottage directly on the west shore of Cayuga Lake in the heart of the Finger Lakes!  Located at lake level, after coming down two flights of stairs, you enter directly on a large porch with
Hot HOT 28
Sheldrake Solitude
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 7 guests
From the eastern facing, panoramic view of Cayuga Lake - to the complete remodel inside; Casa Sul Lago is the perfect Finger Lakes destination.  Minutes from award winning wineries, and just outside downtown historic Seneca Falls this home will have you coming back again, and again.Inside, an open floor plan makes entertaining a breeze. 
Hot HOT 76
Casa Sul Lago
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 10 guests
Located on a quiet and private road, Holiday Cove sits back off the water within a lake community, and enjoys access to the lake and a limited lake view at an affordable rate for larger groups of guests. As you enter the home you will notice that it is decorated with a chic & modern flair. Showcasing hardwood floors in the great room, flat
Hot HOT 63
Holiday Cove
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 12 guests
This split-level gem has amazing, awe-inspiring views that will be sure to take your breath away, and a spacious interior floor plan designed for your comfort in mind.Upon entering A Shore Thing, you will be pleasantly surprised by the welcoming feel of the large four season room. This room provides ample space for enjoying the magnificent views as
Hot HOT 29
A Shore Thing
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 10 guests
Check out this stunning and luxurious 3+ bedroom Cayuga Lake House!  Upon entry into the rear foyer, guests will be greeted with a spectacular view of Cayuga Lake through the windows of the great room.  To the left is the first bedroom, featuring a queen bed and a private en suite bathroom with an oversized tile shower.  To the right
Hot HOT 43
The Lily Pad
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 4 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 10 guests

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree