A Shore Thing

By Lori from Peekskill, New York, Stay: 10/20/2023 - 10/22/2023

As advertised

The house was clean, beautiful, well equipped, a great location. When we had to reach out to property manager for blown circuit they were immediately responsive. Strongly recommend. 

---

Thank you very much for taking the time to rate us 5/5 stars! We are so happy to hear you had such a wonderful time. Please come and stay with us again soon!

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 11/28/2023

By Courtney from Shortsville, New York, Stay: 11/03/2023 - 11/05/2023

Roomie

4 of us ladies stayed here for a weekend. Very spacious and many different areas to separate yourself if you need it. Unfortunately we did not get to take advantage of the game room. We enjoyed the fireplaces in each room. We were doing crafts so we mainly sat in the sunroom the whole time. Great, spacious room. Thinking this might be our new annual place to rent.

---

Thank you very much for taking the time to rate us 5/5 stars! We are so happy to hear you had such a wonderful time. Please come and stay with us again soon!

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 11/28/2023

By Lynne from Downingtown, Pennsylvania , Stay: 09/22/2023 - 09/25/2023

A shore thing

Wonderful home on an amazing lake! Everything was perfect and such a beautiful view! You can't go wrong!

By Thomas from Lakeland, Florida , Stay: 09/02/2023 - 09/09/2023

Nice place

Nice!

By Melanie from Johnson City, New York , Stay: 08/19/2023 - 08/26/2023

Great house

The house was perfect for our family of 4 with more than enough room. I love that we got to bring our dog to enjoy the trip with us. Even when the weather wasn’t great we had plenty to do inside.

By Shawn from Milford, Massachusetts , Stay: 08/05/2023 - 08/12/2023

Place is as advertised

All was good , hot tub, kayaks game room. All was good

By Doris from Blacksburg, Virginia, Stay: 07/15/2023 - 07/22/2023

This property provided a beautiful panoramic view of the lake. It afforded private spaces for a variety of family needs, and had a spacious, open and clean atmosphere. The dock was well maintained and included several beach toys. 

By Laurel from Hamburg, New York , Stay: 05/27/2023 - 06/02/2023

This was one of the best rentals we've had although we've enjoyed all of them.

By Andrea from Watertown, Massachusetts, Stay: 04/15/2023 - 04/20/2023

Perfect location and comfortable home!

We had a group of 9 stay and everything was perfect! We were able to visit many nearby wineries and come back to a peaceful home with a beautiful lake view.

By Christine from Shippensburg, Pennsylvania, Stay: 05/21/2023 - 05/27/2023

Excellent Home

This house has everything you’d ever need! Very convenient location to attractions. Loved our visit to The Finger Lakes!!

By Claire from Denver, Colorado, Stay: 05/04/2023 - 05/07/2023

A shore thing was shorely the best!

Great location, clean, big and a wonderful property right on the lake!

---

Thank you very much for taking the time to rate your experience at our rental. Please come and stay with us again soon!

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 05/26/2023

By Sandy H, Stay: 09/26/2022 - 10/01/2022

Great location, clean and comfortable home. Highly recommend! Being able to bring our dogs along made our vacation even better.

By Susan K, Stay: 09/29/2022 - 10/02/2022

This was a fantastic house to host family and friends and acquaint them with the FLX region. Very spacious, great common areas and game room, decks and dock for enjoying the lake view, etc. The front room/porch provided the most beautiful sunrise views!

By Linda S from Nanticoke, PA, Stay: 12/09/2022 - 12/11/2022

It was a great place for a group getaway. Likely to recommend.

By Heath F from Memphis, New York, Stay: 03/16/2023 - 03/19/2023

Guys weekend

We loved the house and the location. The house was clean and the basement Rec room was a blast. The location on the lake was beautiful. Would highly recommend!

---

Thank you so much for the review and for recommending our rental. We hope to see you again during your next trip to the Finger Lakes.

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 04/03/2023

By Vicki from Great Valley, New York, Stay: 09/11/2022 - 09/14/2022

Lake Trip

The house was very comfortable with many amenities. The early arrival time was greatly appreciated!

---

We are pleased to hear that you enjoyed your recent stay and we hope to host you again. 

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 03/31/2023

By Kevin B,

We cooked for 6 every night, and ran the dishwasher every night.  It would have been nice to have a dish pod for each night.  We did appreciate the extra towel sets and multiple kitchen towels.  It was our second stay at the property and we will be back again.

By Brian H, Stay: 02/16/2023 - 02/22/2023

Very nice location for a long weekend getaway in the winter and centrally located for a wine tour. Beautiful views of the lake, and great entertainment right at the house (pool, ping pong, hot tub, etc.). We would definitely stay here again!

By Joe from Ithaca, New York, Stay: 02/23/2023 - 02/26/2023

A great getaway!

A great property for a family getaway. Beautiful lake views, spacious house, great hot tub, game room, and kitchen made for a nice winter weekend!

---

 Thank you for the 5 star rating. We are happy to see that you enjoyed your stay and we hope to host you again soon.

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 03/27/2023

By Leslie from Ossipee, New Hampshire, Stay: 12/23/2022 - 12/26/2022

Perfect

We had an incredible Christmas as a family in this beautiful home with gorgeous views. Lots of fun!!!

---

Thank you for the 5 star rating. We are pleased that you enjoyed your stay and we hope to see you again soon.

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 02/17/2023

By Nancy S, Stay: 10/04/2020 - 10/08/2020

Spectacular Views!

The house is spacious and comfortable. We loved sitting by the gas fire pit on the front patio! The most mesmerizing feature of the property was the view from inside. We ate every meal in the enclosed front porch. The full wall of windows allowed for a beautiful, expansive view of the lake. The glass doorway into the front porch enabled us to appreciate the same view from inside as we prepared our meals. We would not hesitate to stay there again!!

By Helen B, Stay: 06/06/2021 - 06/12/2021

Wonderful! Great house and Great Location.

The house was clean and well kept. The furnishings were nice. The TVs were amazing.

By Leslie V, Stay: 02/05/2021 - 02/12/2021

A Shore Thing -- Great Property!

A Shore Thing was amazing! It was everything we wanted in a rental. It was spacious, clean, great location and loved the view! We plan on renting once a year for our annual girls weekend!

By Lori G, Stay: 02/27/2021 - 03/06/2021

The Game Room Was GREAT!

We had a very relaxing and enjoyable week. The hot tub was awesome. We even got to have a bonfire by the lake. There were chairs and a table and fire pit for our use. Beautiful view of the lake from the spacious front porch area. Very comfortable furniture in the living room. Would definitely return there. It would be fantastic in the summer. Thanks for a great week!

By Jane G, Stay: 05/08/2021 - 05/12/2021

Family Celebration of Life!

The property was great. Plenty of activities for a family gathering. The amenities were awesome. We thought the whole experience was great.

By Karen H from Bloomingburg, New York, Stay: 04/22/2021 - 04/25/2021

Exceptional! We used to do a girls weekend trip to the Jersey shore every year and haven’t done this is 8 years, so we changed it up and found this GEM, we plan on making this our new place for our girls weekend. And maybe a family trip too. Perfect house with all the amenities one could ask for and the lake is absolutely beautiful!!!!

By Edward H from Richboro, PA, Stay: 06/18/2020 - 06/21/2020

The house is beautiful and in a great location. If you are looking for the perfect getaway home, this is it!

By Erik J from Fairport, New York, Stay: 06/12/2020 - 06/15/2020

This property was the perfect weekend getaway for our family. It was beautiful and very clean and really exceeded any expectation I had for our last minute trip. We really got lucky that this was available! The private back yard was great for my kids to play outside and enjoy the hot tub when they were not down at the dock swimming. The game room was also a huge plus for all of us! We loved everything about this house and would highly recommend it!

By Nancy S from Bear, Delaware, Stay: 08/01/2020 - 08/08/2020

A Shore Thing is an excellent property. The house it spacious and comfortable. The beach and dock are in great repair. There is easy access to the water. The hot tub was a fun and welcome addition. We would definitely stay here again.

By Erik J from Fairport, New York, Stay: 06/12/2020 - 06/15/2020

This property was the perfect weekend getaway for our family. It was beautiful and very clean and really exceeded any expectation I had for our last minute trip. We really got lucky that this was available! The private back yard was great for my kids to play outside and enjoy the hot tub when they were not down at the dock swimming. The game room was also a huge plus for all of us! We loved everything about this house and would highly recommend it!

By Edward H from Richboro, PA, Stay: 06/18/2020 - 06/21/2020

The house is beautiful and in a great location. If you are looking for the perfect getaway home, this is it!

By Stephen H,

October 2019 Stay

My wife and I rented this house for the week after our wedding for our mini-moon. Upon arrival we spotted the house very easily by the Finger Lakes Property Rental sign, which was a nice touch.

We were then greeted with a card and a bottle of wine from the property manager, again a wonderful touch. There was a welcome pack with paper towels, dish soap, etc which also was nice.

The property was extremely clean and had linens and towels in each bedroom. We were very pleased with the layout.

The true gem of the property is the sun room in the front which provided beautiful views of the lake at any time of the day. We spent quite a bit of time in that room every day.

We also loved the addition of the hot tub in the backyard which gave a small peak at the lake from it. The weather was perfect the week we were there so we used the tub each night.

The proximity of the property from Seneca Lake, as well as Cayuga Lake, was ideal. It was 20-25 minutes to great spots on Seneca and less than 45 minutes to Ithaca, which was great too.

Overall we truly enjoyed our mini-moon here and we’re already looking to rent it again.

By Cynthia H,

October 2019 Stay

Lovely home for a getaway. Near wine trails for both Cayuga and Seneca Lakes. Visit New breweries and distilleries with ease. Beautiful views.

By Brian D,

August 2019 Stay

Beautiful view, no reason to leave the house. Dock and beach area were great. Jacuzzi was great for night time. Fit our family perfect. Want to come back next year!!

By Nicole K,

July 2019 Stay

My family had a great time at A Shore Thing. There was plenty of room and we used the kayaks and dock a lot. The house was clean and the yard was huge. I didn't think we would use the Hot Tub but, it ended up being a lot of fun. I would recommend this property.

By Tom T from Bergen, NY,

July 2019 Stay

The property was perfect for our family! We enjoyed our week and had great experiences! We had some issues but they were resolved very quickly! The house is great! It had everything we needed

By Tina M from Halifax, PA,

June 2019 Stay

Beautiful place to stay. Very roomy. Love the view of the lake and the hot tub.

By Allan H from Melbourne,

April 2019 Stay

We did a girls trip and absolutely loved the property! The house was so clean and we enjoyed the hot tub, kayaks and fire pit!! We also enjoyed outdoor grilling. The only thing that could be improved, would be adding a half bathroom. I would still come back to this house, we just loved it and our week there!

By Melissa M,

April 2019 Stay

Amazing property! The house was spotless, beautifully remodeled, with so many amenities. Family and dog friendly, we didn't want our stay to end!

By Donna W from Port Royal, PA, Stay: 06/15/2018 - 06/17/2018

June 2018 Stay

We had a great time and grandchildren had a ball fishing from dock. Also appreciated use of kayaks and paddle boats snd life jackets provided. 

By Todd W from Port Royal, Pa., Stay: 06/16/2018 - 06/23/2018

Great vacation location!
Had a great week. 6 adults and 3 kids. Had plenty of room. Spent most of our time outside on the dock and deck. Excellent dock - kids caught close to 250 panfish from it this week. We also fished from the kayaks and landed a dozen nice pike as well. Saw some big largemouth, but only caught one. Waterfall excursions were well worth the drive and hike. We also recommend Three Brothers winery and brewery and Varick winery which is a mile down the road.

By Patricia Z from Rochester, NY, Stay: 06/08/2018 - 06/09/2018

June 2018 Stay

What a beautiful home with amazing amentities. We will be back for sure. So comfortable and so many things to enjoy!

 

By Marianne M from Lunenburg, MA, Stay: 05/04/2018 - 05/06/2018

May 2018 Stay

I would love to spend more than a weekend here. It is set up for an enjoyable time, no matter the weather. The house was clean, and we appreciated the quality of furnishings and finishes.

 

By Erin W from Warren, PA, Stay: 04/13/2018 - 04/14/2018

April 2018 Stay

Beautiful house and a great location!

 

By Vincent T from Philadelphia, Stay: 03/01/2018 - 03/05/2018

March 2018 Review

Was here with the family for 5 days. Plenty of space, enjoyed the game room, we had movie night, game night and went out bowling. It snowed so we enjoyed time in this fantastic house. We loved waking up to a beautiful view of the lake and we are thinking about a June vacation here, but we'll have to check the rental availability. If you want a great vacation spot, this is it...

 

By Terry E from Getzville, Stay: 08/12/2017 - 08/19/2017

August 2017 Stay

Our family really enjoyed our experience with this rental. Roomy and plenty of seating for the seven of us. Had a great time at dock area but make sure you bring water shoes. We rented a boat, went hiking and toured wineries. Only downfall was poor Wi Fi service. All agreed we would return again some day!!!

By Judy S from Bowie, Maryland, Stay: 05/25/2017 - 05/29/2017

May 2017 Stay

My extended family was in town for a Cornell graduation. We had a wonderful time at this property! My husband and I rent homes when we travel, so we know what to look for and expect in rental properties. A Shore Thing was extremely clean and equipped with all the necessities when away from home. This spacious home is not only nicely decorated and well maintained inside, but outside as well. We enjoyed the meticulously manicured yard and dock area, including the paddle boat, seating areas and multiple fire pits. The younger ones among us enjoyed the game room, too. Highly recommend this property for your next lake vacation.

By Straub,

The home was clean and well equipped. The area around the home was very nice. Quiet street and safe for young kids. I was concerned about the home only having window unit AC but the home was kept cool despite the 90 degree temp outside. The lake is beautiful and clean and surprisingly some days we were the only ones out there. My adult kids enjoyed the bunk house out back which was also very nice for them.

By Susan H. from Wexford, PA,

We stayed at this house while attending my daughter's graduation from Cornell. It was a beautiful house in a beautiful setting. A great place to relax after a exciting but hectic two days full of activities. We were able to host a dinner for her roommates family, which was also quite nice. As a note, we did have two grandparents that have a little trouble with stairs, and we didn't realize how many levels were in the house. We put them on the top floor and everyone got along great. We also loved the game room with the ping pong and pool table. All in all, it was a wonderful house and very comfortable.

By Susan from Wexford PA,

We rented this house for a Cornell graduation weekend and couldn't have been happier. It was a beautiful house with plenty of room for all of our family including grandparents. We couldn't have had a lovelier place to relax after full days of activities on campus. We'd love to return sometime be able to spend more time on the water, in the game room & the lovely 4 season room. Just so beautiful!

By Gail from Flanders NJ,

This is such a beautiful setting - the home is spectacular.

By Mary from Rochester NY,

Great lake rental! My nephew got married at Taughannock Falls and the reception was at Cayuga State Park. Perfect location and great times with family in from out of town!! This is an excellent rental :)

By Pat from Webster NY,

This gorgeous, immaculate house exceeded our expectations! It is very spacious and comfortable. The sun room is the hidden gem since it isn't showcased in the pictures. In this large, beautifully furnished room we spent much time eating, reading, chatting and enjoying the lake view. We loved going over to the lake for fishing, swimming, reading in shade on the lounge chairs or hammock, and the paddle boat was a plus. We would love to return to this house!

By Angela from Milton PA,

I have stayed at many rental homes in & outside of the finger lakes.. This was one of the best homes I've visited in a long time. Quality of everything in the home was top notch. No expense was spared and it really shows. I was very impressed and everyone in our group had an extremely enjoyable stay. Thanks so much!

By Laurie from North Tonowanda NY,

This house was beautiful, clean and was able to comfortably accomodate everyone. We had all ages from toddlers, teens, 20s, 30s, 40s & 50s and there was something for everyone. Everyone loved the game room and the huge porch, paddle boat, a fire and all the TVs. There was enough seating for everyone to sit down for meals and enough room for us all to pile in & watch the game. Wineries are nearby and the view is fantastic. We all loved it!

By Bob & Diane from Elizabethtown KY,

We had a wonderful stay at A Shore Thing! The house is spacious, clean, and well-maintained. The well-equipped kitchen is a dream and the sun deck was perfect for sunrises and games and just relaxing. The game room was great as well. FLPP made our stay here very easy and enjoyable. Would stay here again and highly recommend it to all.

By Darleen from North Syracuse NY,

This was our first time renting a vacation home. This home exceeded our expectations. Every picture online was true! This house is gorgeous and very well maintained. We enjoyed ourselves immensely. The new rec room was a pleasant addition. We would definitely rent this property again.

By Jen from Rossford OH,

This house is incredible. It is spacious, comfortable, and exactly what you always hope for when you rent a vacation home. Inside, there is a pool table, ping pong table, TV's in every door, a whole house stereo system, the couch is really comfy and big enough for lots of people and even the kitchen and deck chairs are comfy. The sunroom off the front of the house is the real star, and the perfect place to watch sunsets and sunrises or play games (which are provided). The beds are comfortable as well, and the master suite is fantastic and includes a whirlpool tub! The kitchen is easy to use and all of the things you need are there. The dock has a hammock, two deck lounge chairs and a table and chair set. The beach is rocky, so bring your swim shoes, for sure. There is also a paddle boat! The house is located within a 10 or fewer minute drive to about 20 different wineries and a reasonably sized town with a grocery store is about 20 minutes away. Overall, this house is one in a million. I can't recommend it enough. You won't be sorry you stayed here!

By Diana from Allen Park MI,

Home was perfect for our family for Cornell graduation.

By Peter from Chester MA,

A Shore Thing was an excellent place to stay. If there was any negative at all, it would be that the house is on Rt 89 and the traffic on that road travels very fast. Going for walks was somewhat difficult, but everything else about the stay was just perfect.