Cottage Rentals Finger Lakes NY
20 properties available
Welcome to Little Piece of Haven, your charming and cozy lakeside retreat on beautiful Keuka Lake! Just minutes from Hammondsport, New York—voted "Coolest Small Town in America"—this two-bedroom Finger Lakes vacation rental is perfect for a couples’ romantic getaway, small families, or a peaceful getaway with friends.Wit
Welcome to your perfect Finger Lakes vacation rental—a charming cottage nestled right on the water’s edge of beautiful Keuka Lake. Located just five miles from the vibrant downtown of Penn Yan, this vacation home offers the best of both worlds: peaceful lakeside living with stunning views, yet close enough to enjoy the area’s loca
Welcome to Lake Haven, a cozy and convenient lakeside escape on Keuka Lake’s east side! Whether you're planning a fun-filled family retreat, a romantic getaway with your special someone, or a group vacation with close friends, this spacious 5-bedroom Finger Lakes vacation rental offers everything you need for relaxation and adventure. Wit
Nestled along a quiet dead-end road, just off the scenic Caywood Vineyards, Lolly’s Cottage is a delightful Finger Lakes vacation rental that offers an authentic and tranquil retreat surrounded by nature. This cozy lakefront vacation home provides the perfect escape for those looking to unwind, reconnect with nature, and immerse themselves in
Nestled on a peaceful five-acre parcel along the western shore of Cayuga Lake, Lucky Stone Cottage is the perfect Finger Lakes vacation rental for families, groups, and friends seeking a relaxing getaway surrounded by nature and renowned wineries. With 150 feet of private lake frontage and easy access to the lake, this three-bedroom, two-and-a-half
Welcome to The Cedar Lodge, a stunning log cabin vacation home nestled on the tranquil shores of Keuka Lake. This beautiful lakefront retreat combines rustic charm with modern luxury, offering guests a perfect Finger Lakes vacation rental where comfort meets nature. With nearly 100 feet of private lake frontage, The Cedar Lodge boasts breathtaking
Welcome to Reel Simple, a beautifully maintained Finger Lakes vacation rental located on the peaceful southern shore of Conesus Lake. This charming three-bedroom, two-bath vacation home perfectly balances rustic cottage warmth with modern comfort, offering guests a serene lakefront escape ideal for families, couples, or friends. Whether you’r
Discover the warmth and charm of Grandma Katie’s Kottage, a treasured Finger Lakes vacation rental that offers guests a truly authentic lakefront experience on the beautiful shores of Keuka Lake. This historic vacation home, passed down through generations, combines nostalgic character with modern conveniences to provide a relaxing retreat fo
Welcome to Serenity Cove, a charming and cozy Finger Lakes vacation rental tucked along the peaceful west branch of Keuka Lake. This inviting lakefront vacation home captures the essence of lakeside living — where time slows down, mornings begin with the gentle sound of lapping water, and evenings end with brilliant sunsets reflecting across
Escape to Nature’s Crossing, a serene and inviting pet-friendly retreat designed for relaxation, rejuvenation, and connection with the beauty of the Finger Lakes. Nestled on a spacious one-acre lot overlooking the north end of Keuka Lake and its surrounding wetlands, this updated ranch-style home is perfect for families, friends, or small gro
Discover a true Finger Lakes vacation rental gem nestled directly on the west shore of beautiful Cayuga Lake, in the coveted Sheldrake Point area. Centrally located between Ithaca, Watkins Glen, and Geneva, this beautiful lakefront vacation home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and breathtaking water views—making it an exceptional
Welcome to Knotty and Nice—a Finger Lakes classic that lives up to its name. Nestled on the peaceful east side of Seneca Lake, this charming 4-bedroom pet-friendly lakefront cottage with space for up to 9 guests offers the perfect blend of rustic character and cozy comfort. Ideally located north of Watkins Glen, it’s a wonderful retreat
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.