Hottest Vacation Rentals in the Finger Lakes

Dreaming of the perfect Finger Lakes escape? Step into 2025’s most buzzed-about vacation rentals—where style, scenery, and serenity collide. These standout properties are turning heads and climbing the charts as travelers race to secure the region’s top stays.

From sun-soaked lakeside retreats to charming countryside cottages, each home on this list was hand-selected for its exceptional character, comfort, and guest-loved appeal. They’re the rentals everyone’s talking about—and they won’t stay a secret for long.

The spotlight is on. The calendars are filling fast. Be among the lucky few to experience what’s next in Finger Lakes vacationing—before everyone else catches on.

Book now and claim your place in the region’s most sought-after stays.

48 properties available

Nestled among award-winning wineries and boasting breathtaking views, Summer Cove offers the ultimate Finger Lakes vacation experience on the east side of Keuka Lake. This lakefront vacation home combines luxurious design, thoughtful amenities, and exceptional comfort to create the perfect getaway for large families and groups. The home includes a

Escape from the everyday and experience lakeside living at its finest at Seneca Shores. Located directly on Seneca Lake and surrounded by the beauty of New York’s Finger Lakes Wine Country, this exceptional six-bedroom, six-and-a-half-bath pet-friendly vacation home offers over 4,000 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. With stu

Olver Farm Cottage welcomes you to experience a true Finger Lakes dream vacation. Nestled just steps from the pristine shores of Cayuga Lake, this newer lake home beautifully blends classic farm charm with modern elegance. Located midway between Ithaca and Seneca Falls, this vacation home offers the perfect home base to explore the best of the Fing

Welcome to Memory Lane, a grand eight-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bath pet-friendly lakefront vacation rental on beautiful Keuka Lake, designed for unforgettable family reunions, milestone celebrations, or group getaways. With three spacious levels of living space, sweeping lake views, and easy access to the Keuka Lake Wine Trail and Penn Yan’s

With a name that says it all, Our Happy Retreat invites you to experience a Finger Lakes vacation filled with comfort, connection, and joy. Located on the desirable east side of Keuka Lake and just minutes from downtown Penn Yan, this spacious lakefront vacation home is designed for families and friends seeking both relaxation and adventure. With s

Welcome to Harmony Hill, a hidden gem in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, where 52 acres of pure tranquility await. Perfect for adventurers, nature lovers, and romantics alike, this beautiful Finger Lakes vacation rental offers a rare combination of seclusion, comfort, and natural beauty. Whether you’re here to explore the outdoors, reco

Discover lakeside living at its finest at English Lake House, a beautifully appointed Seneca Lake vacation rental located on the peaceful east side of the lake. Perfectly designed for families, couples, or groups traveling together, this spacious Finger Lakes vacation home combines comfort, privacy, and breathtaking lake views from every level. Wit

All Decked Out is the perfect getaway for couples or families looking for serene privacy during their vacation. This home features a modern chalet overlooking the lake and nestled in the woods. This delightful property offers a total of 3 bedrooms plus a sleeping loft and 3 bathrooms.A long, winding gravel driveway leads through the woods and

Welcome to The Lily Pad, a breathtaking Finger Lakes vacation rental that promises a luxurious and memorable getaway on the serene shores of Cayuga Lake. This elegant lakefront vacation home offers everything you need to relax, unwind, and explore one of New York’s most beautiful wine regions. Whether you’re planning a family retreat, a

Nestled in a quiet wooded setting on the shores of Seneca Lake, Pine Ridge offers a serene Finger Lakes getaway perfect for couples or small groups seeking a blend of comfort, relaxation, and lakefront charm. Built with tongue-and-groove pine walls and cathedral ceilings, this cozy 3-bedroom lake home with space for up to 4 guests is thoughtfully f

Set on the serene shores of Keuka Lake, Maya’s Palace offers a tranquil and spacious lakeside retreat perfect for families or groups seeking a mix of luxury, comfort, and unforgettable Finger Lakes experiences. Named for the owner’s oldest daughter, this 4-bedroom pet-friendly vacation home exudes a summer-palace charm with nearly 200 f

Maison Du Lac is a stunning 4-bedroom lakeside retreat on Keuka Lake, offering the perfect combination of relaxation, comfort, and style. Whether you’re planning a romantic escape or a family vacation, this beautiful vacation home provides a memorable lakeside experience. With three levels of living space, breathtaking views of the water, and

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

First Name

Last Name

Phone Number

Email Address

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Comments

I agree By filling out this form you are agreeing to receive future information and newsletters regarding Finger Lakes real estate listings, rental properties and trends. Your information will be kept confidential and only used by Finger Lakes Premier Properties. You can unsubscribe at anytime.