Hottest Vacation Rentals in the Finger Lakes

Dreaming of the perfect Finger Lakes escape? Step into 2025’s most buzzed-about vacation rentals—where style, scenery, and serenity collide. These standout properties are turning heads and climbing the charts as travelers race to secure the region’s top stays.

From sun-soaked lakeside retreats to charming countryside cottages, each home on this list was hand-selected for its exceptional character, comfort, and guest-loved appeal. They’re the rentals everyone’s talking about—and they won’t stay a secret for long.

The spotlight is on. The calendars are filling fast. Be among the lucky few to experience what’s next in Finger Lakes vacationing—before everyone else catches on.

Book now and claim your place in the region’s most sought-after stays.

53 properties available

Nestled midway between the historic town of Seneca Falls and the vibrant college city of Ithaca, Regina’s Cottage offers an exceptional Finger Lakes vacation rental experience. This charming lakefront vacation home is perfectly positioned to provide easy access to some of the region’s most popular attractions, while also offering a peac

Experience the ultimate Finger Lakes retreat at The Trottage, a beautiful resort-style cabin nestled along the peaceful western shores of Seneca Lake. This inviting 2-bedroom pet-friendly Finger Lakes vacation rental offers the perfect balance of relaxation and recreation, where comfort meets the natural beauty of New York’s most celebrated w

Discover lakeside living at its finest at English Lake House, a beautifully appointed Seneca Lake vacation rental located on the peaceful east side of the lake. Perfectly designed for families, couples, or groups traveling together, this spacious Finger Lakes vacation home combines comfort, privacy, and breathtaking lake views from every level. Wit

Welcome to Wine to Water, a beautiful three-story lakefront retreat offering 90 feet of private waterfront on the east side of Keuka Lake! Thoughtfully designed for comfort and entertainment, this four-bedroom Finger Lakes vacation rental with space for up to 10 guests provides multiple indoor and outdoor gathering spaces, stunning views, and easy

Welcome to Belle Maison, a luxury lakefront retreat on the peaceful west shore of Canandaigua Lake where breathtaking views, upscale amenities, and unforgettable moments come together. Sleeping up to 12 guests, this beautifully appointed 4-bedroom vacation home is the perfect setting for family vacations, couples' retreats, reunions, and getawa

Tucked away among the trees on the quiet west side of Canandaigua Lake, Hidden House lives up to its name in the best possible way. This custom-built cedar Finger Lakes vacation home offers 124 feet of private lakefront and a peaceful setting surrounded by nature. Combining comfort, privacy, and thoughtful design, it’s the kind of place where

Welcome to The Vineyard House at Fox Run Vineyards, a stunning Finger Lakes vacation rental set in the heart of wine country, surrounded by rolling vineyards and breathtaking lake views of Seneca Lake. This beautifully restored 1870 farmhouse sits directly on the grounds of Fox Run Vineyards, one of the most beloved wineries in the region. Blending

The Vineyard House at Fox Run Vineyards 2

The Vineyard House at Fox Run Vineyards 3

The Vineyard House at Fox Run Vineyards

Experience the ultimate Finger Lakes getaway at Sunset Point, a stunning lakefront home on Keuka Lake offering the perfect combination of relaxation, recreation, and scenic beauty. Surrounded by a park-like setting with mature shade trees and a long, private driveway off East Lake Road, this contemporary 2-bedroom lake home with space for up to 6 g

Welcome to Steinnhus, a breathtaking Finger Lakes vacation rental nestled along the desirable East Bluff of Keuka Lake. This extraordinary estate offers a truly unique vacation home experience, featuring three charming stone buildings surrounded by nature’s tranquility and 200 feet of private lakefront. With sweeping lake views, timeless arch

Tucked among the trees and just minutes from downtown Seneca Falls, Easy Street Getaway offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. Designed in the classic Adirondack style, this inviting 3-bedroom vacation rental with space for up to 8 guests is ideal for families, couples, or friends seekin

Coming in 2026! An additional bathroom and a half will be added to Hook Wine and Sinker! The bedroom to the north will gain a full bathroom and the game room to the south will gain a half bathroom. The description below reflects the property updates with the addition of the new bathrooms.Escape to the beauty of Seneca Lake and ind

Launch the included kayaks just steps from the front door and paddle peaceful waterways lined with wildlife, wooded scenery, and historic canal routes leading toward Keuka Lake. It’s a uniquely relaxing way to experience the Finger Lakes without the premium price tag of traditional lakefront homes.The Keuka Outlet Trail begins just across the

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

First Name

Last Name

Phone Number

Email Address

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Comments

I agree By filling out this form you are agreeing to receive future information and newsletters regarding Finger Lakes real estate listings, rental properties and trends. Your information will be kept confidential and only used by Finger Lakes Premier Properties. You can unsubscribe at anytime.