Hottest Vacation Rentals in the Finger Lakes
Dreaming of the perfect Finger Lakes escape? Step into 2025’s most buzzed-about vacation rentals—where style, scenery, and serenity collide. These standout properties are turning heads and climbing the charts as travelers race to secure the region’s top stays.
From sun-soaked lakeside retreats to charming countryside cottages, each home on this list was hand-selected for its exceptional character, comfort, and guest-loved appeal. They’re the rentals everyone’s talking about—and they won’t stay a secret for long.
The spotlight is on. The calendars are filling fast. Be among the lucky few to experience what’s next in Finger Lakes vacationing—before everyone else catches on.
Book now and claim your place in the region’s most sought-after stays.
52 properties available
Welcome to Fairhaven, a cozy yet spacious Finger Lakes vacation rental located just minutes from Hammondsport, New York—affectionately known as “The Coolest Small Town in America.” Nestled along 54 feet of private Keuka Lake shoreline, this inviting vacation home offers guests the perfect balance of tranquility, comfort, and acces
Set along 50 feet of pristine Canandaigua Lake frontage, Shep’s Lake House is a welcoming family home designed with togetherness in mind—ideal for families and groups looking to slow down and enjoy lake life. Located on a quiet, residential road just south of the City of Canandaigua, the setting offers a peaceful retreat while still bei
Welcome to The Cedar Lodge, a stunning log cabin vacation home nestled on the tranquil shores of Keuka Lake. This beautiful lakefront retreat combines rustic charm with modern luxury, offering guests a perfect Finger Lakes vacation rental where comfort meets nature. With nearly 100 feet of private lake frontage, The Cedar Lodge boasts breathtaking
Welcome to Steinnhus, a breathtaking Finger Lakes vacation rental nestled along the desirable East Bluff of Keuka Lake. This extraordinary estate offers a truly unique vacation home experience, featuring three charming stone buildings surrounded by nature’s tranquility and 200 feet of private lakefront. With sweeping lake views, timeless arch
Discover lakeside living at its finest at English Lake House, a beautifully appointed Seneca Lake vacation rental located on the peaceful east side of the lake. Perfectly designed for families, couples, or groups traveling together, this spacious Finger Lakes vacation home combines comfort, privacy, and breathtaking lake views from every level. Wit
Welcome to The Grape Escape, a stunning contemporary retreat on the west side of Seneca Lake that combines luxurious comfort, modern design, and unbeatable access to the heart of Finger Lakes wine country. Perfectly situated between Geneva and Watkins Glen, this impressive four-bedroom vacation rental with space for up to twelve guests offers a fro
Maison Du Lac is a stunning 4-bedroom lakeside retreat on Keuka Lake, offering the perfect combination of relaxation, comfort, and style. Whether you’re planning a romantic escape or a family vacation, this beautiful vacation home provides a memorable lakeside experience. With three levels of living space, breathtaking views of the water, and
The North Star of Honeoye offers an unforgettable Finger Lakes vacation rental experience, perfectly positioned on the serene shores of Honeoye Lake. This beautiful lakefront vacation home serves as an ideal retreat for families and groups of friends eager to explore the natural beauty, vibrant communities, and renowned wine and beer trails of the
Welcome to Lakeshore Pines, a charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath lake retreat perfectly situated on the highly desirable East Bluff of Keuka Lake—one of the Finger Lakes’ most sought-after locations. Sleeping up to 8 guests and located just minutes from Penn Yan, this home is ideal for Keuka College visits and graduation, weddings at Norton Cha
Welcome to Country Charm, a spacious and inviting 6-bedroom vacation home that blends the ease of modern amenities with the timeless beauty of Keuka Lake. Perfect for family reunions, multi-family vacations, or getaways with close friends, this welcoming pet-friendly retreat with space for up to 12 guests offers the perfect setting for relaxation,
Enjoy your next extended family getaway at Great Adventure on Keuka Lake, a stunning Finger Lakes vacation rental that offers a perfect blend of modern comfort and charming farmhouse style. This spacious vacation home includes a beautifully appointed main house and a cozy guest suite above the detached garage, providing ample space and privacy for
Welcome to Island Vista, a stunning Finger Lakes vacation rental that perfectly captures the beauty, peace, and charm of Canandaigua Lake. Nestled along a quiet private drive on the northwest side of the lake, this spacious four-bedroom vacation home combines modern comfort with serene lakeside living. Whether you’re planning a family getaway
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.