Hottest Vacation Rentals in the Finger Lakes
Dreaming of the perfect Finger Lakes escape? Step into 2025’s most buzzed-about vacation rentals—where style, scenery, and serenity collide. These standout properties are turning heads and climbing the charts as travelers race to secure the region’s top stays.
From sun-soaked lakeside retreats to charming countryside cottages, each home on this list was hand-selected for its exceptional character, comfort, and guest-loved appeal. They’re the rentals everyone’s talking about—and they won’t stay a secret for long.
The spotlight is on. The calendars are filling fast. Be among the lucky few to experience what’s next in Finger Lakes vacationing—before everyone else catches on.
Book now and claim your place in the region’s most sought-after stays.
52 properties available
Welcome to Happy Hour, a beautifully remodeled Finger Lakes vacation rental nestled on the east branch of Keuka Lake, directly across from the tip of the iconic bluff. Perfectly positioned for panoramic lake views, this inviting lakefront vacation home blends classic comfort with modern design, offering an unforgettable escape for families, couples
Welcome to Hygge on Seneca, a sustainably built Scandinavian-inspired 4-bedroom log vacation home that perfectly blends modern comfort with the natural beauty of the Finger Lakes. Nestled within a peaceful forest overlooking stunning Seneca Lake, this recently constructed Pluspuu home—featured in Dwell Magazine—offers a uniquely serene
Welcome to Gracie’s Place, your ultimate Finger Lakes vacation rental—a luxurious six-bedroom vacation home perfectly situated in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. Whether you’re planning a family reunion, a milestone celebration, or a relaxing lakeside getaway, this beautiful property offers the perfect balance of elegance, c
Welcome to Country Charm, a spacious and inviting 6-bedroom vacation home that blends the ease of modern amenities with the timeless beauty of Keuka Lake. Perfect for family reunions, multi-family vacations, or getaways with close friends, this welcoming pet-friendly retreat with space for up to 12 guests offers the perfect setting for relaxation,
Perfectly positioned in the highly sought-after Brandy Bay on Keuka Lake, Brandy Bay Serenity offers luxurious lakeside living with comfort, space, and breathtaking Finger Lakes scenery. With over 120 feet of level private lakefront, this spacious three-bedroom three-level vacation home provides a serene and stylish retreat ideal for family gatheri
Coming in 2026! An additional bathroom and a half will be added to Hook Wine and Sinker! The bedroom to the north will gain a full bathroom and the game room to the south will gain a half bathroom. The description below reflects the property updates with the addition of the new bathrooms.Escape to the beauty of Seneca Lake and ind
Welcome to Memory Lane, a grand eight-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bath pet-friendly lakefront vacation rental on beautiful Keuka Lake, designed for unforgettable family reunions, milestone celebrations, or group getaways. With three spacious levels of living space, sweeping lake views, and easy access to the Keuka Lake Wine Trail and Penn Yan’s
Nestled on the gentle shores of Seneca Lake, Lake Life offers a tranquil escape designed for families who cherish the simple pleasures of lakeside living. This beautiful Finger Lakes vacation rental blends comfort, warmth, and natural beauty, providing everything you need for a peaceful and memorable getaway. Located just minutes from downtown Gene
Welcome to The Lily Pad, a breathtaking Finger Lakes vacation rental that promises a luxurious and memorable getaway on the serene shores of Cayuga Lake. This elegant lakefront vacation home offers everything you need to relax, unwind, and explore one of New York’s most beautiful wine regions. Whether you’re planning a family retreat, a
Welcome to Lone Retreat Lake House, a serene Finger Lakes vacation rental nestled on the peaceful western shore of Cayuga Lake. This luxurious lakefront vacation home offers the perfect combination of modern design, thoughtful amenities, and breathtaking natural beauty. Whether you’re visiting for a family gathering, a friend-filled esc
Welcome to Harmony Hill, a hidden gem in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, where 52 acres of pure tranquility await. Perfect for adventurers, nature lovers, and romantics alike, this beautiful Finger Lakes vacation rental offers a rare combination of seclusion, comfort, and natural beauty. Whether you’re here to explore the outdoors, reco
Welcome to Captain Jack’s II, a cheerful and inviting lakefront vacation home nestled on the northern tip of Keuka Lake’s western branch. Perfectly positioned for watching both sunrise and sunset, this 4-bedroom pet-friendly Finger Lakes vacation rental with space for up to 12 guests offers one of the most peaceful and picturesque setti
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.