Bluestone Cottage

By Alyson from Newburgh, New York , Stay: 07/01/2023 - 07/08/2023

Decided to go to the finger lakes this year for the first time. Using the website and calling to make reservations was very easy the house was as described, although the furniture could be upgraded. Beautiful, setting nice amenities and a very sweet gift bag from finger lake properties. Will be going back to the finger lakes next year.

By Courtney from Washington, Pennsylvania , Stay: 06/22/2017 - 06/25/2017

June 2017 Stay

We loved our stay . The pictures don't do the inside enough justice . It was perfect for a girls weekend . Close enough to wineries ,but far enough out to enjoy a peaceful quiet evening on the lake.

By Chris from Fairfield, Connecticut , Stay: 06/11/2023 - 06/16/2023

The location of our home was second to none. We really enjoyed the outdoor patio, hot tub, grill, and dock access. A nice rental for a family or group intending to spend most of their time outdoors!

By Emily W from Penn Yan, Stay: 06/05/2020 - 06/07/2020

The Bluestone Cottage was everything we were dreaming and more, we were spoiled with the fancy boat lift for our fishing boat and it was so nice to have the boat whips for our cruising/tubing boat to keep safe at the dock as well. Each night we enjoyed a campfire in the pit with S'mores and started each morning in the hot tub with coffee. This rental is a true lake cottage and filled every single must we had on our list when choosing a vacation rental. Andrea in reservations was very efficient and kind to work with as we booked this rental 2 months ago. While Josh in property services was great to work with when communicating a couple small fixes to improve the next guests stay. We will definitely be booking with Finger Lakes Premier Properties again and hope to stay in august or September. Thank you for helping us create new memories on Keuka Lake with our friends and family!

By Karissa E from Dallas, Pennsylvania, Stay: 06/07/2020 - 06/14/2020

Wonderful getaway with family memories to last a lifetime! We recently stayed at the Bluestone Cottage. I can't begin to express what a great week we had. It's a beautiful cottage with many great amenities. The patio area with fire pit was awesome. There was great fishing from the dock and I spent each morning in the hot tub. The most amazing sunsets and drifting asleep while listening to the water. Can't wait to return! Thanks again for the wonderful stay!

By Todd K from Spencerport, New York, Stay: 06/21/2020 - 06/28/2020

Great Location and great water front area.

By Kathleen H from Columbia, Maryland, Stay: 06/28/2020 - 07/05/2020

Excellent. It was exactly what was advertised except for the parking. We’ll cherish our family memories and would love to return for more.

By Martha S from Auburn, New York, Stay: 07/05/2020 - 07/12/2020

This is the second time we stayed at The Blue Stone Cottage. We love the location and the house.

By Thomas D from Flemington, New Jersey, Stay: 07/26/2020 - 08/02/2020

We had a great time at Bluestone Cottage. Location right on the lake is awesome. There is a walk in area of the beach that is perfect for putting kayaks into the water or just walking in. The dock itself is a bit high for getting onto a paddle board but we managed. The dock, deck, fire pit and hot tub were all in great shape and used regularly during our stay. Inside the WiFi actually works which is not always the case up in the FLX. The cottage itself has everything you need and the air conditioning was up to the task on the days when temperatures moved into the 90s. We had a great time and would recommend Bluestone Cottage to anyone.

By Carissa W from Rochester, Stay: 08/17/2020 - 08/23/2020

Amazing Views, Incredible Patio and Waterfront
We had a lovely stay. The outdoor area was incredible. The patio, dock, and pebble beach were exactly what we were looking for and the hot tub was wonderful during the cooler evenings. We enjoyed kayaking and fell in love with the West Bluff!

By Todd K,

August 2019 Stay

Good location with incredible sunsets. Good waterfront patio and dock space. Good swimming.

By Debbie K,

August 2019 Stay

Our family has used FLPP for at least 15 years now starting out at Seneca Lake and now at Keuka Lake. We have never been dissatisfied with any of our rentals. This cottage was no different as it was the fourth time we have stayed here. It never disappoints! No complaints with the service or the rental.

By Nathan Z from Arlington, VA,

July 2019 Stay

We had a fabulous week on Keuka Lake. Finger Lakes Premiere Properties made for a smooth and enjoyable experience. We loved our rental house, the adults and kids had a blast, and we definitely plan to come back and rent again.

By Courtney G from Washington, Stay: 06/22/2017 - 06/25/2017

June 2017 Stay

We loved our stay. The pictures don't do the inside enough justice . It was perfect for a girls weekend . Close enough to wineries, but far enough out to enjoy a peaceful quiet evening on the lake 

By Christa from Middle River MD,

Thank you for the great service. If you are looking for a private secluded getaway, it's a great spot.