Captain Jack's II

Rating 4.8 (21 Guest Reviews)
Bedroom 4 bedrooms
Bathroom 2 full baths
Guests 12 guests
Pets Allowed Pets Allowed

  • Lake: Keuka Lake
  • Location: Lakeside
  • Square Feet: 1400
Location

GET ONE NIGHT FREE!

Get one night free when you book 3 or more nights. You must arrive between 1/13/26 and 4/30/2026.  Don’t miss this limited-time offer—secure your stay today!

Use promo code STAY3FOR2 at checkout to save today!

*Offer expires 04/30/2026 and you must book your vacation between 01/13/2026 and 04/30/2026.

Location

Galentine’s Weekend

Cayuga Lake wine trail

February 13th, 2026 OR February 14th, 2026

Galentine’s Weekend is all about celebrating friendship, laughter, and treating yourself. Whether you’re toasting to your ride-or-dies, taking a break from the daily grind, or simply craving a girls’ day out, this event pairs perfectly with your vibe.

  • πŸ₯‚ A souvenir wine glass

  • 🍹 A cocktail or spritzer at every winery (mocktails for the DDs!)

  • 🍷 Three additional wine tastings per stop

  • πŸ§€ Snack-style bites inspired by the viral #GirlDinner trend. Think cheese, crackers, fruit, pickles, chips & more!

  • πŸ“– A recipe book to recreate your cocktails, spritzers, or mocktails at home

  • 🎁 A bingo-style ticket that enters you into a luxury spa giveaway — because self-care is always in style.


Tickets: $25 a single | $20 a DD

  • DD Ticket Available ($20) (includes food and non-alcoholic options at each stop).

Add your tickets at check out when you book your vacation rental. You will receive an e-ticket for each ticket purchased after booking.

Your starting winery will be Cayuga Ridge.

*Offer expires 02/14/2026 and you must book your vacation between 02/12/2026 and 02/16/2026.

Location

Pinch & Pour

Cayuga Lake Wine Trail

February 21st & 22nd, 2026

Embark on a flavorful journey along the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, where each winery will highlight a unique spice-inspired pairing. From the cozy sweetness of cinnamon to the earthy depth of cumin, the zesty bite of ginger, or the comforting warmth of paprika, you’ll discover how spices transform food and wine in surprising ways. With each stop offering its own twist, this event is your chance to explore bold, unexpected flavors that turn winter into a feast for the senses.

Each ticket includes:

  • 1 spice-inspired wine & food pairing at every winery
    Each winery is assigned a unique spice that inspires their featured bite and is gifted as a take-home spice jar (one per ticket).
  • 3 additional wine tastings per stop
  • A different spice jar at each stop — matches the winery’s featured spice
  • A printed recipe book with all featured spice pairings
  • A souvenir wine glass to take home
  • Price includes all 10 participating wineries: Buttonwood Grove Winery, Cayuga Ridge Estate Winery, Hosmer Winery, Lucas Vineyards, Montezuma Winery, Six Eighty Cellars, Six Mile Creek Vineyard, Sheldrake Point Winery, Swedish Hill Winery, Thirsty Owl Wine Co.

Tickets: $85 a couple | $55 a single

  • DD Ticket Available ($35) (includes food and non-alcoholic options at each stop).

Add your tickets at check out when you book your vacation rental. You will receive an e-ticket for each ticket purchased after booking.

Your starting winery will be Cayuga Ridge.

*Offer expires 02/22/2026 and you must book your vacation between 02/19/2026 and 02/23/2026.


Location Location

Description Description
Welcome to Captain Jack’s II, a cheerful and inviting lakefront vacation home nestled on the northern tip of Keuka Lake’s western branch. Perfectly positioned for watching both sunrise and sunset, this 4-bedroom pet-friendly Finger Lakes vacation rental with space for up to 12 guests offers one of the most peaceful and picturesque settings on the lake. With level, grassy grounds that stretch right to the water’s edge, it’s an ideal retreat for families, couples, and even your furry companions looking to relax and reconnect in the heart of the Finger Lakes region.

As you arrive, a short set of stairs leads you inside, where the open and comfortable living room welcomes you in. Overstuffed furniture and a large flat-screen TV create a cozy space to unwind after a day of swimming or sightseeing. Gather here for a family movie night or simply enjoy the company of loved ones while the evening breeze drifts in through the windows. The living area opens into the bright and spacious full kitchen and dining room, perfectly designed for shared meals and easy entertaining. Featuring sleek appliances, ample cabinet space, and a convenient island with seating for two, the kitchen makes cooking for a crowd simple and enjoyable. The adjacent dining area features a large table positioned in front of sliding glass doors that frame stunning lake views. Whether you’re savoring your morning coffee or sitting down to a homemade dinner, the view of Keuka Lake’s sparkling waters provides the perfect backdrop.

Just off the dining room, a laundry area adds convenience for longer stays, while the vacation home’s main suite sits toward the back, offering privacy and comfort. This serene bedroom features a queen bed, a wall-mounted flat-screen TV, and a private ensuite bathroom with dual sinks and a full-size shower. Two additional bedrooms are located off the main living room—one with a queen bed and another with a twin-over-double bunk bed—along with a second full bathroom featuring a shower and tub combination.

Head upstairs to find a bright and spacious recreation area that promises fun for guests of all ages. Watch the game on the large TV or challenge friends and family to a round of ping-pong or foosball. With a second sleeper sofa and plenty of space to lounge, this area doubles as an extra hangout zone for kids or an additional sleeping area when needed.

Step outside and experience what makes this Finger Lakes vacation rental so special. The large back deck overlooks the lake and grassy yard, offering plenty of room for outdoor meals, sunbathing, or simply watching the water glisten. The level yard below is perfect for children to play safely while adults relax nearby. When you’re ready for a swim, head down to the natural entry shoreline, which is ideal for wading, paddling, or simply dipping your toes in the cool water. Cast a line from the seasonal dock and see what you can catch, or settle into an Adirondack chair as the sun sets in a wash of orange and gold across the lake. As evening falls, relax around the fire pit with a glass of Finger Lakes wine and listen to the soothing sounds of the water.

Located just outside the charming village of Branchport, Captain Jack’s II places you within easy reach of local wineries along the Keuka Lake Wine Trail, breweries, and outdoor adventures. Spend the day exploring Keuka Lake State Park, just a short drive away, or visit nearby tasting rooms to sample the region’s award-winning wines and craft beers. Outdoor activities in the Finger Lakes region are abundant, such as horseback riding near Seneca Lake, fishing in Cayuga Lake or Canandaigua Lake, and hiking at Watkins Glen State Park, among other options.

With its peaceful location, open layout, and family-oriented amenities, Captain Jack’s II is the perfect place to slow down, soak in the beauty of Keuka Lake, and make lasting memories together. Book your stay today and experience the best of the Finger Lakes region in comfort and style!

Per New York state and county regulations, the occupancy for this property is strictly limited. The maximum occupancy stated on this listing is the number of guests allowed on the premises at any given time, including infants and children. This includes both day and overnight guests, no exceptions. 

Note: 
1. Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. This includes vaping and e-cigarettes. 
2. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in the description.
3. Air conditioning is not available unless listed as an amenity. If available, air conditioning is considered a seasonal amenity and is only available May 15 - October 15.
4. Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets.
5. Docking capabilities may vary based on current water levels. Docking is not guaranteed if water levels are low and/or high due to seasonal weather and climate changes.
6. Outdoor amenities, including furniture, watercraft and firepit are not available between October 15 - May 15.

Property Details Property Details
  • Boat Lift: None
  • Lake Frontage: 35' (Natural)
  • Nearest Launch: Keuka Lake State Park
  • Vehicle Parking: 3 Spaces
  • Pet Restriction: 2 Dogs Allowed
  • Dock: 4' x 48' (Water Approx. 2' Deep at End of Dock)
  • Slope of Lot: Level
  • Steps to Beach: 4
  • Stairs to Property: 4
  • Sewer: Septic
  • Water Source: Public

Bed and Bath Bed and Bath
  • Bedroom 1 - Queen - Entry Level
  • Bedroom 2 - Queen - Entry Level
  • Bedroom 3 - Twin-over-double - Entry Level
  • Bedroom 4 - Queen - Second Floor
  • Living Room - Sleep Sofa - Entry Level (Sleeper Sofa is a Queen)
  • Family Room - Sleep Sofa - Second Floor (Sleeper Sofa is a Queen)
  • Bathroom 1 - Toilet,Shower - Entry Level
  • Bathroom 2 - Toilet,Combo Tub Shower - Entry Level

Amenities 47 Amenities
  • Accessibility Wheelchair Inaccessible
  • Cable/satellite TV
  • Central heating
  • Coffee Maker
  • Dryer
  • Enhanced Cleaning Practices
  • Grill ( Propane)
  • Internet Access
  • Internet ( Wireless)
  • Microwave
  • Minimum Age Limit ( 25)
  • Non-motorized watercraft ( Paddleboat)
  • Oven
  • Parking space Accessible
  • Patio Or Balcony
  • Pets Considered
  • Refrigerator
  • Satellite or Cable ( Cable TV)
  • Stove
  • Toaster
  • TV
  • Wifi
  • Boat Cleats or Tie-Off
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Central Air
  • Deck Patio Uncovered
  • Dishwasher
  • DVD player
  • Fire Pit
  • Foosball
  • Game room
  • Heating
  • Linens provided
  • Ping Pong Table
  • Smoking Not Allowed
  • Television
  • Towels provided
  • Washer/Dryer

Reviews Rating 4.8 (21) Reviews
Rating 5
The weather was BEAUTIFUL! We had a rental kayak delivered to the property for the week and used it almost every day. Paddling on that part of the lake is amazing! We explored the shore line and the inlet, and really enjoyed the birdwatching. This was our first time staying on this part of Keuka Lake and loved every minute of it. I will definitely be back!
Mary O - Stay Date: 8/30/2025
Rating 5
The tubing on the lake with our grandchildren, the beautiful views down the lake, and all the activities (e.g.: wineries, breweries, restaurants, etc.) close bye.
John M - Stay Date: 7/5/2025
Rating 5
Captain Jack's is the ideal place for our family and we would love to rent it again next year.
John M - Stay Date: 8/10/2024
Rating 5
The house has an excellent location and can accommodate a big family.
Scott And Marybeth - Stay Date: 7/6/2024
Rating 5
Excellent vacation, small quaint towns but just a short drive to view the other lakes.
Allison C - Stay Date: 6/15/2024
Rating 4
Nice escape
The property overall was great. The house was located on a private road with about 10 other lakefront properties. It was walking distance to some trails which was nice to hike with the family. The house was well maintained on the inside and met our needs with kids and adults. Kitchen was fully stocked with all the necessary pots, pans and utensils to make dinner and breakfast. The house contained life vests in a bin in the laundry room that could be used for the paddle boat. The playroom with ping pong table was a huge hit with the kids. The only minor complaint would be the cobwebs covering the outside furniture and entry way to the house. Found a broom to take care of them. Would rent again if looking for a nice house to relax on the lake.
Ashley P - Stay Date: 5/24/2024
Thank you very much for taking the time to review your stay at Captain Jack's II We will use your feedback to improve the experience for future guests at this rental. Please come and stay with us again soon!
Finger Lakes Premier Properties staff
Posted: 6/17/2024
Rating 5
Absolutely wonderful stay. The welcome bag for our dog was a very pleasant surprise. The house was exactly the right size for our family. The view of the lake was phenomenal. So peaceful! Kitchen was beautiful and well stocked with the essentials. Can't wait to come back!
Tracy R - Stay Date: 5/30/2024
Rating 5

We had a wonderful time with our children and grandchildren, enjoying kayaks and paddleboat on the water, indoor activities when it rained, and hiking at nearby locations. 

Kenneth L from Lititz, Pennsylvania - Stay Date: 9/7/2023
Rating 5
Perfect place to Celebrate College graduation

This place is a slice of heaven. Location was perfect and the fact that there are few stairs was very important for our older family members. The home is better in person, so spacious and welcoming. All the cooking utensils you could think of. The stress instantly leaves you as you sit on the patio overlooking the lake. We booked an extra night just so we didn't have to leave at checkout. The owners take great pride in making sure the house is perfect.

Annette M from Cheektowaga, New York - Stay Date: 5/20/2022
Rating 5
June 2017 Stay

What a great location. We had a family vacation to celebrate our 40th wedding anniversary and the accommodations did not disappoint. We had everything we needed and more. This was our first visit to the Finger Lakes Region and we will be back. Thanks for sharing this home with us.

Marilyn S from Beaver Dam, Wisconsin - Stay Date: 6/24/2017
Rating 5

Our family had a wonderful time at your beautiful home. Kitchen had all the items needed to prepare our meals. Beautiful view and easy access to the lake. Very quiet street. Walking distance to the nature trail.

Ann P from Monroe Township, Pennsylvania - Stay Date: 8/29/2020
Rating 5

The property was great with its level yard and shallow lakefront. We liked the location - a quiet street with easy parking, not far from the state park. We loved Captain Jack's and would definitely recommend it!

Judy S from Hastings On Hudson, New York - Stay Date: 5/30/2020
Rating 4

Nice location, everything you need for a nice family getaway

Patrick C from Penfield, New York - Stay Date: 6/20/2020
Rating 5

Comfortable and spacious. Grassy area and shallow water great for small children. Mature tree provides shade.

Lucy M from Fairport, New York - Stay Date: 7/11/2020
Rating 5
November 2019 Stay

Property was very comfortable and well appointed. Everything in great condition. Worked very well for our family!

Michael R - Stay Date:
Rating 5
August 2019 Stay

This was the perfect spot for 4 kids under the age of 8, 2 grandparents and 4 adults to really relax and enjoy the incredible view and waterfront. We loved kayaking up the Branchport inlet and testing out the paddle boats. The water was clear and p

Julie D - Stay Date:
Rating 5
July 2019 Stay

A comfortable home with good access to the home as well as to the water. Nice shallow entry.

Lucy & John M - Stay Date:
Rating 5
Highly Recommend!

Wonderful.  This is a fantastic home, located on a beautiful property.  We highly recommend.

Tim F from Angola, NY - Stay Date: 9/9/2018
Rating 5
Excellent property.

Excellent facility and location. Level entrance from parking area to house and level, shallow entrance to water made access for small children very workable.

Lucy & John M from Fairport, NY - Stay Date: 7/7/2018
Rating 5
June 2017 Stay

What a great location. We had a family vacation to celebrate our 40th wedding anniversary and the accommodations did not disappoint. We had everything we needed and more. This was our first visit to the Finger Lakes Region and we will be back. Thanks for sharing this home with us.

Marilyn S from Kalamazoo MI ; Baltimore MD; Richmond VA - Stay Date: 6/24/2017
Rating 4
Great spot! Have been coming for years and love the level lot and not having to hike down a steep slope to get to the cottage. While the shallow water has it's issues, it is also nice to be able to wade out and not worrying about going over your head.
Ted - Stay Date: 6/29/2013
Swipe Swipe for More Reviews

Have a question? Customer Questions & Answers Have a question? Customer Questions & Answers

Want to know specifics? Ask anything about this specific property that you would like to know...

Example: "Is the balcony screened in?" or "Is there a toaster oven?"


Request More Info Request More Info

Want to know specifics? Ask anything in reference to vacationing at this property that you would like to know...

Example: "Are fresh linens provided?"

I agree