Cayuga Gray

Rating 4.9 (11 Guest Reviews)
Bedroom 3 bedrooms
Bathroom 2 full baths
Bathroom 1 half baths
Guests 8 guests
Pets Allowed Pets Allowed

  • Address: 5233 St Rt 89
  • Lake: Cayuga Lake
  • Location: Lakeside
  • Peak Check In: Friday
  • Square Feet: 2300

Location Location

Description Description

Directly on the water amongst the areas finest Finger Lakes Wineries and located on the west shore of Cayuga Lake you will find this exceptional colonial style home we call “Cayuga Gray”.

As you enter this home from the lake you are greeted with a sunny all season’s room with large wall to wall picture windows for an all-day view of the water.  Inside the Living Room you are met with a massive stone fireplace (decorative only) and cozy seating.  The living room is open to an updated kitchen that includes a breakfast bar and modern appliances.  The lakefront Dining Room boast views of the sparkling lake.

Upstairs you will find a master bedroom with Queen bed and an attached bathroom equipped with jetted tub.  Enjoy your morning coffee from the upper deck off the master suite.  Just down the hall are 2 more bedrooms. One with a Queen bed and the other with both a Queen bed and Twin bed to accommodate your entire family.

This home offers you 95’ of gorgeous shoreline with a break wall, firepit and 30’ permanent dock.  The boathouse offers easy access to launch a kayak and paddleboard directly into the water.

Exploring Finger Lakes wine country couldn’t be easier than from this location. Within 10 miles you have access to a dozen award-winning wineries including Hosmer, Thirsty Owl, Knapp, and the infamous Three Brothers Winery and Brewery. For any history buffs, Seneca Falls is also a short drive away.

* Note: Your safety is important to us! This home is equipped with 2 exterior security cameras. The cameras do not look into any interior living spaces. 

**This property is closely monitored for responsible renting and must abide by Town of Varick Rental Guidelines; this includes limiting guest occupancy to 10 at all times.

Occupancy: This property is closely monitored for responsible renting.  The maximum occupancy of each home is the number of guests allowed on the premises at any given time.  This includes both day and overnight guests. 

Note: Smoking is not allowed in any rental property.
Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in description.
Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets.
Docking capabilities may vary based on current water levels. Docking is not guaranteed if water levels are low and/or high due to seasonal weather and climate changes.
* Outdoor amenities, including furniture/ watercraft/ fire pits, are not available between October 15- May 15 * 

Property Details Property Details
  • Boat Lift: Manual Lift up to 3400 lbs
  • Breakwall: 95' Frontage
  • Nearest Launch: Deans Cove Boat Launch (2 Miles)
  • Vehicle Parking: 2 Spaces, No Additional Parking Permitted
  • Dock: 3'x30' Permanent
  • Pet Restriction: 2 Dogs Allowed
  • Sewer: Septic
  • Slope of Lot: Level
  • Steps to Beach: 3
  • Stairs to Property: 20 or Paved Path
  • Water Source: Public

Bed and Bath Bed and Bath
  • Bedroom 1 - Queen,Bunk Bed - Second Floor
  • Bedroom 2 - Queen - Second Floor
  • Bedroom 3 - Queen - Second Floor
  • Bathroom 1 - Toilet,Shower - Second Floor
  • Bathroom 2 - Toilet,Jetted Tub,Shower - Second Floor
  • Half Bath - Toilet - Entry Level

Amenities 17 Amenities
  • Air Conditioning (Mini-Split located in upstairs guest bedroom)
  • BBQ - Propane
  • Boat Cleats or Tie-Off
  • Dishwasher
  • Dryer
  • Enhanced Cleaning Practices
  • Fire Pit
  • Fireplace (Decorative Only)
  • Heating (Radiant Floor and Baseboard)
  • Internet (Wireless)
  • Linens provided
  • Minimum Age Limit (25)
  • Non-motorized watercraft (1 Kayak, 1 Paddleboard, 1 Double Kayak)
  • Premier Property
  • Smoking Not Allowed
  • Towels provided
  • Washer

Reviews Rating 4.9 (11) Reviews
Rating 5
Great Getaway!!
We really enjoyed our stay at the Cayuga Gray on Cayuga Lake! The house was very clean and roomy and was perfect for our little getaway! The kitchen does not have a crockpot just as an FYI but other than that no complaints. Great place to stay!!!
Audra Y - Stay Date: 4/11/2024
Thank you very much for taking the time to rate your experience at our rental. Please come and stay with us again soon!
Finger Lakes Premier Properties staff
Posted: 5/13/2024
Rating 5
Great stay!
Cayuga Gray is a lovely, pet-friendly home! We plan to return!!
Jennifer G - Stay Date: 12/14/2023
Rating 5
Wonderful vacation home
We enjoyed our stay at this beautiful vacation home. It was comfortable, clean, and well maintained. Our only issue was that we could only park two cars at the house due to new regulations. We needed to park the extra car in a nearby parking lot.
Cheryl S - Stay Date: 10/6/2023
Thank you very much for taking the time to rate us 5/5 stars! We are thrilled to hear you would definitely come back and stay again!
Finger Lakes Premier Properties staff
Posted: 2/5/2024
Rating 5
A great location for our girls weekend in the finger lakes.
There was plenty of space and we love opening the door and being right on the water. We ate in a couple of nights and had great use of the kitchen and the living room was great for lounging.
Meghan L - Stay Date: 11/2/2023
Rating 5

Overall, very nice. This was our 4th or 5th time renting from you and it is always enjoyable.

Mark K from Swampscott, Massachusetts - Stay Date: 8/11/2023
Rating 5
Relaxing get away

We had a lovely stay at Cayuga Gray. There was plenty of room for eight of us. The accommodations were very clean and modern. The beds were comfortable. The kitchen was well stocked. There were plenty of games and puzzles provided as well as plenty of storage for food, clothing, etc. The barbecue outback worked out well and we were able to use the fire pit. The views of the lake from the living room, as well as the front porch are wonderful! Nice area outside to sit either in the sun or the shade. The provision of the kayaks was so convenient. Being centrally located on the lake was nice to be able to take advantage of a lot that was in the area. There was an unexpected issue with a tree branch that needed to be removed. Both the realtor and the homeowners were very responsive. The only recommendation that I would make would be for more chairs and maybe a long table on the front porch, which would provide more variety of seating and eating options. We would definitely stay here again!

Carolyn P from Chatham, New Jersey - Stay Date: 8/18/2023
Rating 5

Cayuga Gray is very comfortable, and its location on the lake fantastic, with immense views. Although its proximity to Rte. 89 means you can hear road noise, this was not an issue and it was very quiet at night.

Lawrence F from New Milford, Connecticut - Stay Date: 7/7/2023
Rating 4
Cornell Graduation Weekend 2023

Beautiful, airy home on a lake with lots of sunlight. Gorgeous sunrises. Can't beat the sounds of the lake and the brilliance of the sun reflecting on the water, as you drink your morning coffee. Well stocked kitchen, tons of extra pillows and covers. We used the kayaks and fished from the dock. Lots of nice wineries within 5-20 min drive. We ate at Wolffy's which is right on the lake 10 min away. Great food. Overall great stay and we would love to stay here again.

Olga B from Brooklyn, NY - Stay Date: 5/25/2023
Rating 5
Lovely property…we plan to return!!
Jennifer G - Stay Date: 10/2/2022
Rating 5
Great location & floor plan

Great house & would recommend renting it. The house is right on the lake with access directly into the lake. Upper deck for beautiful views or in the warmth of the entry room. The home was modern, simple, tastefully decorated & clean. The kitchen has everything you need to prepare meals-it was very well stocked. Plenty of games & puzzles, extra blankets & pillows if you need them. Beds are comfortable. Please note that it is a three bedroom property with additional sleeping areas available on the pull-out couch in the entry room & a trundle bed in an area off to the side of the master bedroom. There are three actual bedrooms with doors/privacy. To access the shower in the master bedroom, you step into the Jacuzzi tub-not an issue, but good to know if someone has mobility issues & is planning on using that bathroom. The other bathroom has a standard stand-up shower (no tub). Shower pressure was good & bathrooms had plenty of room for storage. Property was very clean & well maintained. Living area downstairs has a great open floor plan for hanging out & a 1/2 bathroom is right off of the living room. Wineries are very close by. About 1/2 hour drive to Ithaca and 1 hour to Greek Peak. We really enjoyed our stay in this home & would recommend it to others.

Christa V from Collingswood, New Jersey - Stay Date: 12/27/2022

Thank you very much for taking the time to rate your experience at our rental. We are extremely gratified to see that you enjoyed a wonderful stay with us! Please come and stay with us again soon!

Finger Lakes Premier Properties staff
Posted: 2/17/2023
Rating 5
New Years Weekend

The home- Cayuga Gray- was absolutely lovely. It was just as pictured with great sleeping space for our family and nice gathering areas with great views of Lake Cayuga. Great sunrise through the cloud cover of a December morning from the bedroom balcony. Nice kitchen with all the necessary tools to cook meals and bake. Great place and we look forward to coming back with the entire family.

Kristen K from Chester Springs, Pennsylvania - Stay Date: 12/30/2022

Thank you very much for taking the time to rate your experience at our rental. We are thrilled to see that you enjoyed a wonderful stay with us! Please come and stay with us again soon!

Finger Lakes Premier Properties staff
Posted: 2/17/2023
Swipe Swipe for More Reviews

Have a question? Customer Questions & Answers Have a question? Customer Questions & Answers

Want to know specifics? Ask anything about this specific property that you would like to know...

Example: "Is the balcony screened in?" or "Is there a toaster oven?"

Request More Info Request More Info

Want to know specifics? Ask anything in reference to vacationing at this property that you would like to know...

Example: "Are fresh linens provided?"

I agree