Welcome to Fossil Beach, a timeless Finger Lakes vacation rental that perfectly blends history, privacy, and lakeside charm. Nestled along the peaceful west shore of Canandaigua Lake, this beloved cottage-style vacation home captures the essence of classic lake living while offering the modern comforts today’s travelers appreciate. Whether you’re here for family fun, a quiet retreat surrounded by nature, or an adventure-filled getaway on the water, Fossil Beach provides the perfect setting for your next Finger Lakes escape.
Built in 1920, this historic lake cottage embodies the spirit of old-fashioned Finger Lakes hospitality. Set on a heavily wooded lot far from the main road, the home offers a serene, secluded environment where the only sounds you’ll hear are the gentle lapping of waves and the rustle of leaves in the breeze. It’s a place where time slows down — a sanctuary for those who crave peace, simplicity, and connection.
Step through the small covered porch into the cozy main living area, where warmth and character immediately welcome you in. A decorative fireplace anchors the space, surrounded by comfortable seating that invites you to unwind after a day on the lake. Large picture windows and glass doors frame captivating views of Canandaigua Lake, filling the home with soft natural light and making you feel connected to the water from nearly every angle. Whether you’re gathered for a family movie night, reading a favorite book, or simply enjoying good company, this open, inviting space feels like the heart of the home.
The adjoining kitchen and dining area offer everything you need to make mealtime easy and enjoyable. The fully equipped kitchen features modern appliances, generous counter space, and all the cookware and utensils you’ll need to prepare your favorite dishes. The dining area comfortably seats your entire group, creating the perfect setting for home-cooked meals, lively conversation, and laughter that carries late into the evening.
Upstairs, Fossil Beach continues to charm with its cozy, cottage-style bedrooms. The master suite offers a luxurious king-size bed and a private ensuite bathroom, providing a peaceful sanctuary for rest and relaxation. Additional bedrooms are thoughtfully furnished with comfort and function in mind, some featuring partial lake views that make waking up a joy. Each space carries the home’s vintage charm — from its sloped ceilings to its timeless wood accents — creating a nostalgic yet comfortable atmosphere. A shared full bathroom ensures convenience for all guests.
One of the most enchanting spaces in the home is the screened porch off the second floor. Overlooking the trees and lake, this airy retreat is ideal for slow mornings or restful afternoons. Relax with a good book, sip coffee while listening to the birds, or enjoy an afternoon nap as the soft breeze drifts through. Beginning in 2024, this porch will feature a twin daybed with a trundle, offering additional sleeping space for family or friends who want to fall asleep to the sound of the lake.
Outside, Fossil Beach offers an outdoor paradise for those who love the water. With over 335 feet of private lakefront, guests can swim, paddle, or fish right from the property. The gradual, walk-in shoreline makes water access easy for guests of all ages, while the private dock provides the perfect spot to cast a line or simply relax in the sun. For guests who prefer exploring, non-motorized watercraft are available to use, allowing you to glide across Canandaigua’s calm waters and discover hidden coves and quiet stretches of shoreline.
When evening arrives, gather your group around the lakeside firepit for one of the property’s most magical experiences. The crackle of the fire, the shimmer of moonlight on the water, and the laughter of loved ones create the kind of moments that define a truly special vacation. Roast marshmallows, share stories, and watch as the night sky fills with stars — all from your private lakeside retreat.
Beyond the property, Fossil Beach’s prime location offers easy access to some of the Finger Lakes’ most beloved attractions. Just 20 minutes south lies the village of Naples, a charming town known for its boutique shops, farm-to-table restaurants, and the famous Naples Grape Festival, which celebrates the region’s harvest every fall. Outdoor enthusiasts will love visiting Grimes Glen Park, where waterfalls and shallow pools invite you to hike, splash, and explore. Head north toward Canandaigua for even more dining, shopping, and entertainment options, including local breweries, waterfront restaurants, and scenic boat tours.
For guests visiting in winter, the adventure continues. The area offers skiing and snowboarding at Bristol Mountain, snowshoeing through the surrounding hills, or simply cozy evenings by the fire as the snow falls outside. Because the home sits on a gradual slope, guests are advised to use four-wheel drive during snowy months for easy access and peace of mind.
Every detail at Fossil Beach has been thoughtfully designed to create a stay that feels both effortless and extraordinary. The combination of its historic character, spacious interiors, and private lakefront setting make it an ideal choice for families, groups, or anyone seeking to experience the authentic charm of the Finger Lakes. The wooded lot ensures privacy, while the open floor plan and expansive outdoor spaces encourage connection and togetherness — the hallmarks of a perfect lake getaway.
Whether you’re spending the day kayaking along the shoreline, exploring nearby wineries, or relaxing on the dock with a glass of local Riesling, Fossil Beach offers a rare blend of comfort, tranquility, and natural beauty. This vacation home isn’t just a place to stay — it’s a place to create memories that will stay with you long after your visit ends. Book your stay at Fossil Beach today and experience a Finger Lakes vacation rental that embodies the best of lake life: peaceful mornings, starry nights, and timeless moments shared with the people who matter most.
**4-Wheel Drive is recommended for all winter bookings! **
Occupancy: This property is closely monitored for responsible renting. The maximum occupancy of each home is the number of guests allowed on the premises at any given time. This includes both day and overnight guests.
Note:
1. Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. This includes vaping and e-cigarettes.
2. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in the description.
3. Air conditioning is not available unless listed as an amenity. If available, air conditioning is considered a seasonal amenity and is only available May 15 - October 15.
4. Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets.
5. Docking capabilities may vary based on current water levels. Docking is not guaranteed if water levels are low and/or high due to seasonal weather and climate changes.
6. Outdoor amenities, including furniture, watercraft and firepit are not available between October 15 - May 15.
- Boat Lift: None
- Lake Frontage: 380' (Natural)
- Nearest Launch: German Brothers
- Pet Restriction: 2 Dogs Allowed
- Dock: 4' x 100' (Seasonal) - Boats are not able to be tied to the dock
- Slope of Lot: Gradual - Steep
- Steps to Beach: 40
- Stairs to Property: 3
- Vehicle Parking: 5 Spaces
- Sewer: Septic
- Water Source: Lake
- Bedroom 1 - King - Second Floor
- Bedroom 2 - Queen,Bunk Bed - Second Floor
- Bedroom 3 - Queen,Twin Single - Second Floor (Bunk Set)
- Bedroom 4 - Queen,Twin Single - Second Floor (Bunk Set)
- Bedroom 5 - King - Second Floor (Twin Daybed with Twin Trundle can be converted to KIng)
- Bathroom 1 - Toilet,Shower - Entry Level
- Bathroom 2 - Toilet,Tub,Shower - Second Floor
- Bathroom 3 - Toilet,Shower - Second Floor
- Accessibility Wheelchair Inaccessible
- Churches
- Coffee Maker
- Enhanced Cleaning Practices
- Fireplace ( Gas Fireplace in Living Room)
- Grill ( Propane)
- Internet ( Wireless)
- Iron
- Iron Board
- Library
- Microwave
- Minimum Age Limit ( 25)
- Mooring Buoy ( All motorized boats should be tied to the mooring buoy, not the dock)
- Non-motorized watercraft ( Row Boat, Canoe, Kayak and Paddleboat)
- Oven
- Refrigerator
- Stove
- Toaster
- Blender
- Central Air
- Dishwasher
- Fire Pit
- Heating
- Hot Tub
- Linens provided
- Screen Porch
- Smoking Not Allowed
- Television
- Towels provided
- Washer/Dryer
Want to know specifics? Ask anything about this specific property that you would like to know...
Example: "Is the balcony screened in?" or "Is there a toaster oven?"