Knotty and Nice

Welcome to Knotty and Nice—a Finger Lakes classic that lives up to its name. Nestled on the peaceful east side of Seneca Lake, this charming 4-bedroom pet-friendly lakefront cottage with space for up to 9 guests offers the perfect blend of rustic character and cozy comfort. Ideally located north of Watkins Glen, it’s a wonderful retreat for families, couples, and friends alike—whether you’re planning a weekend at the racetrack, a scenic wine tour, or a relaxing lakeside getaway!

From the moment you arrive, Knotty and Nice greets you with warmth and charm. The open-concept living and dining area is cozy and inviting, with a decorative fireplace that adds just the right touch of nostalgia. Settle into the comfortable seating for an evening of conversation or enjoy a home-cooked meal at the dining table for four. The adjacent kitchen is compact but fully equipped, making it easy to prepare everything from quick breakfasts to lakeside dinners. And with views of Seneca Lake in the distance, every moment spent here feels connected to the peaceful beauty of the region.

With four comfortable bedrooms—two on the main level and two upstairs—there’s plenty of space at this Finger Lakes vacation rental for everyone to unwind. Each bedroom features a queen bed, and one upstairs room also includes a twin bed, perfect for a child or extra guest. Whether your view is of the garden or the lake, you’ll find each space thoughtfully appointed for rest and relaxation after a day of exploring.

Step outside to the lakeside deck, where mornings begin with sunshine and coffee, and evenings invite long, slow dinners under the stars. There’s plenty of room for outdoor dining and lounging, and just a short walk away, a grassy area leads you to the water’s edge. The gradual slope makes lake access easy for guests of all ages, and the permanent dock is perfect for fishing, sunbathing, or simply watching boats drift by. A boat lift is available for guests bringing their own vessel, making this vacation home an ideal base for boating adventures on Seneca Lake.

Located across the street from the lake on a quiet dead-end road, this cottage offers a peaceful atmosphere while still being close to all the best Finger Lakes region’s attractions. Enjoy a scenic morning walk or bike ride down the lane, or take a short drive to explore local wineries and breweries. Popular destinations like Wagner Vineyards, Boundary Breaks, and Bagley’s Poplar Ridge Vineyards are all nearby.

For a day of adventure, head 20 minutes south to Watkins Glen State Park, where you can hike through the famous gorge and waterfalls. The village of Watkins Glen also offers a variety of restaurants, shops, and lakeside experiences—including boat tours with Captain Bill’s Cruise. Guests who prefer a quieter day can stay closer to home, reading on the deck, taking a refreshing swim, or simply relaxing around the fire pit in the peaceful lakeside air. When it comes to outdoor activities, consider a day spent fishing in Cayuga Lake or Canandaigua Lake, kayaking around Seneca Lake, or boating on Keuka Lake.

This Finger Lakes vacation rental is designed for those who love both connection and calm—the kind of place where days are unhurried and evenings are spent gathered together by the water. With space for up to nine guests, pet-friendly accommodations for two dogs, and easy lake access, this charming lake home the perfect setting for making lasting Finger Lakes memories. Whether you’re here for a wine weekend, a family vacation, or simply to unwind in nature, you’ll find everything you need and more at Knotty and Nice. Book your stay today and discover why guests return year after year to this beloved Seneca Lake retreat!

Per New York state and county regulations, the occupancy for this property is strictly limited. The maximum occupancy stated on this listing is the number of guests allowed on the premises at any given time, including infants and children. This includes both day and overnight guests, no exceptions.

Note: 
1. Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. This includes vaping and e-cigarettes. 
2. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in the description.
3. Air conditioning is not available unless listed as an amenity. If available, air conditioning is considered a seasonal amenity and is only available May 15 - October 15.
4. Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets.
5. Docking capabilities may vary based on current water levels. Docking is not guaranteed if water levels are low and/or high due to seasonal weather and climate changes.
6. Outdoor amenities, including furniture, watercraft and firepit are not available between October 15 - May 15.