Riesling Rod and Reel

By Alison from Grand Island, New York , Stay: 08/12/2023 - 08/19/2023

A great location on Honeoye Lake.  The house was laid out perfectly for families, especially families with small children.  

By Debbie from Poughkeepsie, New York , Stay: 08/25/2023 - 09/03/2023

We went as a family to Celebrate my Husband's 10th year Heart Transplant anniversary.  We brought extra items for the kitchen we thought we would need but didn't need any of the items as it was full equipped.  There was plenty of space for the 8 adults and we didn't feel we were on top of each other.  The yard was big and we didn't feel like we were on top of the neighbors. Really enjoyed out time there and can't wait to go back.   

By Cynthia from Fairport, New York , Stay: 07/21/2023 - 07/27/2023

Family Vaca

This is a very nice home. Nice shore line to the lake and lots of shade. We were a little disappointed that there were NO kitchen staples (flour, sugar, mustard, ketchup, mayo, oil, vinegar), but there is a little grocery store on the other side of the lake. Description said to bring outdoor chairs, but there were plenty there.

By Barbara from Hamburg, New York , Stay: 07/27/2023 - 07/30/2023

Wonderful family getaway

This beautiful home was situated right on the lake with many amenities. Fun for the entire family! We really enjoyed our stay. Would highly recommend!

By Diane from Cicero, New York , Stay: 06/24/2023 - 07/03/2023

Not what we hoped for

The house was nice and the layout was as well, but the photos are a bit deceiving when it comes to the size of the living areas. We were disappointed with the lake itself. We have stayed on other Finger Lakes and were not overly familiar with Honeoye Lake as much. Researching the lake didn't save us. We weren't able to into the water on any of the ten days of our stay. The lake struggles with frequent algae blooms which can be a health hazard. It also is dominated by seaweed which we had to remove from the shoreline for the one day when the algae didn't bloom. It's a pretty location but we came prepared to have fun in the water with our grandchildren and that didn't happen. We won't look to rent a property on Honeoye Lake ever again during the summer months. This would be a lovely location for the fall when water fun isn't what you're seeking.

By Riley & Mary Jo from Erie, Pennsylvania , Stay: 06/17/2023 - 06/20/2023

Quiet and relaxing getaway

My family had a wonderful time! The house and town are quiet and relaxing. The house was spacious for the 6 of us and had so many amenities. Wish we could’ve stayed longer! If you want to go out to wineries and breweries I highly recommend Canandaigua lake area which is only 25 min from the house! Our favorite brewery was Other Half Brewing company and our favorite restaurant was Nolan’s for a delicious Father’s Day dinner.

By Alexis from Springville, New York , Stay: 06/09/2023 - 06/15/2023

Wonderful week away

The property was gorgeous and exceeded our expectations. There were tons of things for our kids to play with and the rooms accommodated all of our families. Highly recommend and will be coming back.

By Rosanna K, Stay: 07/17/2022 - 07/24/2022

This was our second time staying at this house.  We enjoy the comfort, spaciousness,  and location. Can't think of anything else it needs!

By Paula T from Milton, DE, Stay: 09/14/2022 - 09/19/2022

Beautiful well maintained property. Clean and very accommodating. We will be back. Thank you!

By Karen D, Stay: 09/23/2022 - 09/26/2022

Only found 1 spatula. Could definitely use more. Nonstick cookware was worn. Other kitchen amenities were good. Beds were comfortable. Backyard was nice. Enjoyed the large firepit. Adirondack chairs were a nice surprise.

By Colleen from Marilla, New York, Stay: 05/06/2022 - 05/08/2022

Mother's Day Weekend

Loved the Riesling Rod & Reel and will defiantly rent this property again perfect for our family. House was so nice & perfect. We all loved having the lake just steps away and enjoyed the outdoor area day and night - very nice fire pit for night time smores. House is so very comfortable and relaxing plenty of room for my sisters family and mine to celebrate Mothers Day with our Mom.

By Bridget from West Seneca, New York, Stay: 10/08/2021 - 10/11/2021

Great find

What a great VRBO! Everything was clean and the house was prepped with whatever you need. Great place for families- it was very kid friendly and there were even toys, strollers etc. We thoroughly enjoyed our time at the house and would definitely recommend. The grill and outdoor fire pit were perfect. Twisted Rail Brewery and Sandy Bottom Nature Trail are both super close. There was a lot of algae in the lake but due to the time of year we weren’t planning on swimming so it didn’t bother us. Thanks for having us!

---

Thank you so much for the review and for recommending our rental. We hope to see you again during your next trip to the Finger Lakes.

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 11/01/2021

By Karen from Woodside, California, Stay: 09/09/2021 - 09/14/2021

Nice comfy stay

Clean house, nice yard with all the amenities and the added benefit of being dog friendly.

---

Thank you for the 5 star rating. We are happy to see that you enjoyed your stay and we hope to host you again soon.

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 09/30/2021

By Jason from Mars, Pennsylvania, Stay: 06/13/2020 - 06/20/2020

Amazing remote getaway

We had a wonderful time relaxing by the lake. Row boat and kayaks were available whenever we wanted to venture out on the lake. This house is a hidden gem. Beautiful all around.

---

Thank you for the 5 star rating. We are happy to see that you enjoyed your stay and we hope to host you again soon.

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 09/02/2021

By Stacy J, Stay: 09/04/2020 - 09/07/2020

FIVE STARS!

What a great home and great location! This house by far had more amenities than any other rental property we have stayed at. My family and I had a great time. Here are some tips for future renters at this property: -There is no dishwasher -There is a crockpot, a lot of silverware, ice cube trays, a nice microwave, a nice stove and oven, real plates, pretty much a fully equipped kitchen, spatulas, serving spoons, grill utensils, etc. -Lots of toddler/baby toys, pack & play, high chair seat that sits on the chair -Nice grill w/ propane -Outdoor table and chairs that seats 8 -I would suggest bringing your own bath towels or bringing extra. Some towels are provided. -BRING KITCHEN TOWELS, OVEN MITTS, POT HOLDERS, DISH RAGS-none of these items are in the house. Probably Covid related reasons. -Really nice washer and dryer are in garage. -Due to Covid, all sheets and bath towels are wrapped and left on your bed so when you arrive you can unwrap them and put the sheets and pillow cases on yourself. (unless you decide to bring your own) -Dog friendly! -We rented a pontoon from Trident Marina! -Check out twisted rail brewery...good drinks and food. Located right at the Trident Marina down the road. -Cable TV in living room -Neighbors are close, but that is to be expected at lake houses usually. -There is a 7-11 store couple of miles up the road -Bring extra blankets. Every bed only has one blanket on it (like a thin quilt) Which is fine in the summer but by labor day weekend, it was chilly at night and we did bring our own extra blankets. -Nice gas fireplace in living room -Very clean house! Well kept. -Loved that the water was just a few short steps away from the house and you don't have to walk down steep stairs, like many lake houses have. -Didn't catch one single dang fish. Oh well. Had a great time!!!

By Rosanna K from Corning, New York, Stay: 07/26/2020 - 08/02/2020

We always feel at home at this house, and we will keep coming back! So much space, huge bedrooms, and a great lake view of the north end of the lake.

By Barbara H from Churchville, New York, Stay: 07/16/2020 - 07/20/2020

Fishers Paradise

It was wonderful to stay in such a wonderful place and share special time with our children and grandchildren.

By Paul D,

September 2019 Stay

We are very satisfied with the property the cleanliness and the amenities we would definitely recommend this property to our friends for future rental

By Rosanna K,

August 2019 Stay

This was our 5th year spending a week on Honeoye lake for our family vacation (12 of us). The house was very comfortable and each bedroom was huge compared to other houses we stayed in. Kitchen had everything we needed, and was a bonus to have an extra pack and play and high chair seat for the little ones. Great week!

By Heather M,

August 2019 Stay

I had a wonderful experience renting through Finger Lakes Premier Properties. Any time I had a question, there was always someone available and friendly to assist. The ease of renting through this company was fantastic and communication was great. Absolutely no issues with our rental for the time we were there. Exactly as expected, maybe even a better view than expected. Very clean and everything we would have needed was right there. I would highly recommend renting through this company, we definitely will in the future!

By Natalie G,

June 2019 Stay

This house was one of our favorite vacation rentals in 19 years of marriage. Honeoye is a small town and quiet. The house offers the perfect opportunity to relax and spend time with family. We kayaked, rowed, fished, picnicked, played, and just watched the water for days.

By Connie & Don M,

January 2019 Stay

Great place for a winter holiday. Neighborhood is very quiet and secluded and the lake is a real jewel

By Connie and Don M from Bradley Beach, NJ, Stay: 12/22/2018 - 12/28/2018

Great place for a winter holiday

Great place for a winter holiday. Neighborhood is very quiet and secluded and the lake is a real jewel.

By Claudia R from Pittsford , Stay: 09/21/2018 - 09/25/2018

Perfect Reunion
My 4 siblings & spouses spent a long weekend at this beautiful place. The house is beautiful, impeccably kept, and perfectly equipped. The lake is steps away from the back deck. Plenty to do in the area, but it was hard to leave the house, as we loved the large eating area, comfy living spaces, and the yard, lake and fire pit! I highly recommend this place!