Sheldrake Solitude

By Jennie from Wyoming, Michigan , Stay: 07/20/2023 - 07/24/2023

There isn’t a doubt in my mind that your staff strives to go above and beyond with every customer interaction. I *always* had a positive experience on the phone with each person I talked to. The app was handy to have, we loved the packing list and other pre-visit communication, and were so pleasantly surprised by the gift bag upon arrival. What a nice touch! We were saying if we ever own property on the Finger Lakes we already know we would use your company to manage our property. Your staff is the best! 

By Meaghan from Syracuse, New York , Stay: 08/09/2023 - 08/13/2023

Beautiful setting on the lake

The stairs are no joke, so pack light. The house is dated, but sufficient. Could definitely use some updating and the cleanliness was lacking. The lake view, kayaks, and dock were awesome. Recommend Wyckoff Farms stand down the road. We had a fun, comfortable stay next to quiet neighbors.

By Jennifer & Larry from Rochester, New York, Stay: 07/09/2023 - 07/16/2023

We had a wonderful stay. Morning coffee listening to the waves, walking the dogs along the quiet street and enjoying the beautiful views, fun fishing off the dock, and lots of wildlife to watch including bald eagles, osprey, herons, and a family of playful mink. Location was great and we didn't have to drive far to restaurants, wineries, Ithaca, hiking trails and parks. Cottage had everything we needed, and the dock was really nice. Thank you!

By Christine from Reading, Pennsylvania , Stay: 06/30/2023 - 07/07/2023

Our overall rental experience was great! The description of the property and it’s amenities were spot on. Our group loved the spacious home right on the lake. I appreciated emails containing all important information about check in as well as check out. I would definitely look to rent here again if we visit the Finger Lakes.

By Amanda from Bethlehem, Pennsylvania , Stay: 07/16/2023 - 07/19/2023

Peaceful and just perfect!

We loved our stay! Beautiful home- right in the water with a great dock and swimming area. Great beds, linens and a well stocked kitchen. We brought pizza dough and there was a pizza pan- score! Quiet lake, great wildlife and quiet neighbors. Please stop by the Wyckoff farms stand, it’s just down the road and has amazing produce and a burger pack to bring home to grill- so good! The kayaks were a wonderful perk and our kids loved it too!

By Gwen from Grove City, Pennsylvania , Stay: 06/26/2023 - 06/30/2023

Location, location, location

The cottage is situated in a perfect location. It is quiet and serene. We enjoyed sitting on the dock in the mornings, and on the covered porch when it rained. We walked in the mornings and it was pleasant, as the road was not busy. We saw a lot of birds, including an American Eagle soaring past the cottage. It is located close to some wineries. Sheldrake Point Winery is a little over a mile down the road - our favorite on Cayuga. We visited Cornell Lab of Ornithology which was only about a 45 minute drive. A few suggestions to improve the rental - replace outdoor grill and the toaster. Add another air conditioner downstairs. Put a blind in the upstairs window so people walking down the steps cannot see in. Also, it appears the owner has issues with carpenter bees. We were surprised by an exterminator one morning at 7AM while we were enjoying coffee on the porch. He was not informed there were guests, and we were not informed of his coming. He sprayed the sides of the house while we were there and was going to come back to spray the porch.

By Jay from Lakewood, Ohio, Stay: 06/12/2023 - 06/17/2023

We were very pleased with the unit and it’s location. The pier was great to sit on at all points of the day. Everything was great and any issues were certainly normal and to be expected. We would very much like to return to this unit in the future. 

By Jay from Lakewood, Ohio, Stay: 06/12/2023 - 06/17/2023

Great place

Great place in a great location. Had one minor issue with a smoke detector but the property management company was attentive and quick responding which was great. A lot of stairs but we expected that. We have no complaints and would happily return to this specific property and stay again

By Shannon from Hannibal, New York , Stay: 06/02/2023 - 06/04/2023

Perfect Winery Getaway Lake-house!

Wonderful stay for a winery bachelorette celebration this weekend. It was extremely clean, stocked, and perfect for what we were looking for! The only hiccup occurring in the check in process in which I was not contacted with the check in info same day as previously told. However, the customer service is quick and responsive, and this was immediately remedied with a short phone call! The view could not be beat, waking up to the water every morning was a dream! The road had almost no traffic making it perfect for morning walks. We even met some of the neighbors while out and they were so friendly and welcoming! Would definitely stay here again and recommend to anyone!

By Chris from New York, NY, Stay: 05/06/2023 - 05/12/2023

Lively lakeside retreat

Great, well appointed house right on the lake. Beautiful lake views from kitchen, living room and even the shower! The brand new dock was a wonderful spot to take in the calm lake views. Wyers Point Rd. Had little traffic, so it was nice going for walks everyday. Looking forward to visiting again.

By Jeanne T, Stay: 10/12/2022 - 10/16/2022

I like the location of this house and the setting is very nice on the lake.  There are 40  stairs to the property, which can be a problem for someone with physical difficulties.

By Cassandra L from Bellevue, OH, Stay: 10/16/2022 - 10/19/2022

Simply perfect. There were even welcome bags for my dogs. The house was cozy and relaxing. The dock was everything I wanted for sunrises and star gazing. Coffee on the porch each morning was a delightful way to start each day.

By Debra B, Stay: 09/30/2022 - 10/03/2022

I loved the location and the view. The house was perfect for a long weekend getaway for my husband and I.

By Debra from Newark, Delaware, Stay: 09/30/2022 - 10/02/2022

Amazing view!!

We loved being right on the lake. The views were amazing and we could hear the water lapping against the shore. The house was very comfortable and had everything we needed for our long weekend. My only concern was I didn't realize we would be required to go down multiple steps to get to the house. I would have packed differently if I had known.

---

Thank you very much for taking the time to rate your experience at our rental. We are thrilled to see that you enjoyed a wonderful stay with us! Please come and stay with us again soon!

- Finger Lakes Properties staff, Posted: 03/30/2023

By Ginger S from Greater Rochester area, Stay: 09/16/2022 - 09/23/2022

Quiet, quaint and comfortable
..a very nice lake cottage in a beautiful setting