Posted on 3/25/2024

4 of the Best Places to Find Finger Lakes Antiques

Finger Lakes antiques

4 of the Best Places to Find Finger Lakes Antiques

If you're looking for antique stores near the Finger Lakes, you're in luck! There are plenty of great options from which to choose. Whether you're looking for a souvenir for the antique-lover in your life or you're on the hunt for a beautiful piece to adorn your home, you're sure to find something interesting and beautiful. No matter which lake you're staying near, you'll be able to browse through some great Finger Lakes antiques!

This blog post will share our top tips for planning the perfect antiquing vacation in the Finger Lakes. Need more planning information? Read our vacation guide to read about everything from restaurants to events going on in the region! 

Find the Best Finger Lakes Antiques at These Stores

Geneva Antique Co-Op

One of our favorite Finger Lakes antique trails is Geneva Antique Co-Op. Located in Geneva, NY, the co-op is a 6,000 square foot, two floor antique/collectible cooperative. You can find whatever you are looking for with one of 70+ dealers at affordable prices. 

Crossroads Antiques of Lima

One of the best Finger Lakes antique malls is Crossroads Antiques of Lima. While it may be a bit of a drive from the lakes, it's definitely worth it. The mall features over 50 dealers in the 7,000 square-foot building. This is a great place to find antique jewelry or vintage clothing. If you're searching for the perfect gift for that rare book lover, be sure to stop by. Not sure what you're browsing for? With so many amazing dealers and such a wide selection, you're sure to find something exciting and new-to-you!

Pastimes Antiques

If you're staying along Cayuga Lake, you'll definitely want to stop by Pastimes Antiques. Open since 1979, this small shop is jam-packed with fun and affordable items. They're centrally located in downtown Ithaca, making this a great stop during a day trip to the town. This is one of our favorite antique stores in the Finger Lakes region. Find out why after just one visit!

Ponzi's Antiques

Another great antique shop near Cayuga Lake is Ponzi's Antiques. This store has been in operation for over 40 years and is owned by Paul and Connie Polce. They boast a large selection of 18th and 19th-century furniture and accessories, as well as artwork, glassware, folk art, whale-oil lamps, clocks, and more! Get a full look at all they have to offer in their showroom.

Wild Goose Chase Antiques

If you've ever needed to find the most obscure, random antiques, why not go on a WIld Goose Chase when you visit Hammondsport, NY. The shop overlooks Keuka Lake and offers an authentic antique experience replete with items inside and out the massive antique barn. 

Stay with Finger Lakes Premier Properties

Are you ready to find some incredible Finger Lake antiques? The first step is to book a home with Finger Lakes Premier Properties. We have beautiful rental properties located on the shores of six lakes in the region. With our incredible, 24-hour guest service and housekeeping guarantee, it's easy to see why so many visitors keep coming back!

Browse our full selection of rental homes and book today! We look forward to having you.

Previous Our favorite spring fishing spots Explore the Best of the Finger Lakes Cheese Trail Next