View All Rentals
Escape to the Finger Lakes with Finger Lakes Premier Properties! Your search for the perfect lakefront vacation home starts here, choose from your favorite amenities like waterfront access, kayaks, hot tubs, pet-friendly, neighboring wineries and so much more!
Set your search filters and begin planning the perfect vacation. For further assistance, contact our local vacation planners in our online chat or calling 888-414-5253 opt 1.
We look forward to hosting you in the Finger Lakes!

208 properties available
Nestled among the rolling hills just north of downtown Watkins Glen and tucked between the trees, Watkin’ Lakeside is a charming 3-bedroom vacation rental with space for up to 8 guests that captures the best of Finger Lakes living. This peaceful home has everything you need and more for a quintessential getaway—where comfort, convenienc
Watkin' Lakeside
Seneca Lake
3
bedrooms
3
Full baths
8
guests
Welcome to West Lake Reserve, Canandaigua Lake's newest luxury custom home and one of the Finger Lakes' most extraordinary private vacation rentals. Brand new and never before offered as a vacation home, this stunning lakefront estate combines timeless architecture, sophisticated design, and breathtaking waterfront views to create an unforg
West Lake Reserve
Canandaigua Lake
6
bedrooms
5
Full baths
12
guests
Set along 50 feet of pristine Canandaigua Lake frontage, Shep’s Lake House is a welcoming family home designed with togetherness in mind—ideal for families and groups looking to slow down and enjoy lake life. Located on a quiet, residential road just south of the City of Canandaigua, the setting offers a peaceful retreat while still bei
Shep's Lake House
Canandaigua Lake
5
bedrooms
3
Full baths
10
guests
Escape to Summer Haven, a stunning two-story lakefront vacation rental in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Country. With 80 feet of private waterfront, multiple outdoor living spaces, and expansive interiors designed for comfort and relaxation, this 5-bedroom retreat with space for up to 8 guests is perfect for families or groups seeking both lux
Summer Haven
Keuka Lake
5
bedrooms
4
Full baths
8
guests
Tucked away in a quiet neighborhood just steps from the shores of Canandaigua Lake, Greenbriar Getaway offers a peaceful retreat perfectly situated for enjoying the best of the Finger Lakes region. This beautifully updated three-bedroom vacation home blends modern comfort with the relaxed spirit of lakeside living. Whether you’re here for a f
Greenbriar Getaway
Canandaigua Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
8
guests
Nestled along a peaceful, private road just off the renowned Keuka Lake Wine Trail, midway between the charming towns of Penn Yan and Hammondsport, you’ll find Dozens of Cousins — a beautifully remodeled Finger Lakes vacation rental designed with large families and friend groups in mind. This spacious lakefront vacation home offers the
Dozens of Cousins Main House
Keuka Lake
5
bedrooms
2
Full baths
10
guests
A short drive from Ithaca, this recently remodeled three bedroom, two bath home is boasting with lakefront fun. Leave all your cares at home and enjoy “Cayuga Lakeside!”Inside, views of Cayuga Lake shine through the wall to wall windows that span the length of the open floor plan. Wooden flooring allows the light to beam in
Cayuga Lakeside
Cayuga Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
1
Half baths
8
guests
Olver Farm Cottage welcomes you to experience a true Finger Lakes dream vacation. Nestled just steps from the pristine shores of Cayuga Lake, this newer lake home beautifully blends classic farm charm with modern elegance. Located midway between Ithaca and Seneca Falls, this vacation home offers the perfect home base to explore the best of the Fing
Olver Farm Cottage
Cayuga Lake
2
bedrooms
2
Full baths
4
guests
Nestled on the serene shores of Honeoye Lake, Honeoye Haven invites you to experience the perfect Finger Lakes vacation rental. Whether your plans include a peaceful fishing trip, exploring the breathtaking Letchworth State Park, or simply unwinding amidst stunning natural beauty, this lakeside vacation home offers everything you need for a memorab
Honeoye Haven
Honeoye Lake
4
bedrooms
2
Full baths
8
guests
Sunrise Shores is a stunning Finger Lakes vacation rental perfectly situated on the peaceful and natural northwest shore of Seneca Lake. This charming waterfront vacation home offers an ideal blend of classic lakeside character and modern comforts, making it the perfect retreat for guests of all ages seeking relaxation, adventure, and memorable fam
Sunrise Shores
Seneca Lake
4
bedrooms
3
Full baths
12
guests
Welcome to Sunset Chalet, an inviting Finger Lakes vacation rental that captures the quiet beauty and timeless charm of Honeoye Lake. Nestled at the end of a private lane, this picturesque lakefront home offers soaring cathedral ceilings, an open-concept design, and panoramic views that bring the outdoors in. Whether you’re looking for a peac
Sunset Chalet
Honeoye Lake
4
bedrooms
2
Full baths
12
guests
Welcome to Wolffy’s House on the Hill, a charming three-bedroom, pet-friendly getaway overlooking beautiful Cayuga Lake! Conveniently located between Ithaca and Seneca Falls, this inviting retreat puts you close to wineries, waterfalls, local dining, and plenty of Finger Lakes adventures.Inside, the bright and comfortable main level is design
Wolffy's House on the Hill
Cayuga Lake
3
bedrooms
1
Full baths
9
guests
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Finger Lakes Premier Properties
All Rights Reserved.