Cayuga Lake Wine Trail Vacation Rentals
Vacation in one of the best lakefront vacation rentals along the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail when you attend one of their signature wine events. Fully loaded for your whole group to enjoy the best of lake living in the Finger Lakes.
The Cayuga Lake Wine Trail is America's first wine trail. It features a few wineries that are accessible by boat, and ALL wineries are pet-friendly!
For more information on the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, including some of their iconic events, click here.

53 properties available
Discover the ultimate Finger Lakes getaway at Aurora Escape, a six-bedroom, four-bath vacation home perfectly positioned on the east side of Cayuga Lake in the heart of historic downtown Aurora. This remarkable lakefront home combines timeless elegance with modern comforts, offering an ideal setting for families, friends, or multi-generational grou
Aurora Escape
Cayuga Lake
6
bedrooms
4
Full baths
12
guests
A short drive from Ithaca, this recently remodeled three bedroom, two bath home is boasting with lakefront fun. Leave all your cares at home and enjoy “Cayuga Lakeside!”Inside, views of Cayuga Lake shine through the wall to wall windows that span the length of the open floor plan. Wooden flooring allows the light to beam in
Cayuga Lakeside
Cayuga Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
1
Half baths
8
guests
Charming, modern, and perfectly situated for a true Finger Lakes escape, Petit Retreat lives up to its name as one of the most delightful cottages on Cayuga Lake. Just minutes from downtown Seneca Falls and steps from the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, this beautifully designed two-bedroom pet-friendly vacation rental with space for up to four guests is i
Petit Retreat
Cayuga Lake
2
bedrooms
1
Full baths
1
Half baths
4
guests
Tucked along a quiet road overlooking the sparkling waters of Seneca Lake, Heron House is a peaceful lakefront retreat designed with relaxation and comfort in mind. From the moment you arrive, this beautifully decorated pet-friendly 4-bedroom vacation home welcomes you to unwind, slow down, and enjoy the simple pleasures of lake life in New York&rs
Heron House
Seneca Lake
4
bedrooms
2
Full baths
8
guests
Nestled on the eastern shore of Seneca Lake, The Willows offers a charming Finger Lakes vacation rental that combines stunning lakefront views with cozy comfort. This delightful vacation home is perfectly suited for couples or small extended families seeking a peaceful retreat in the heart of Seneca Lake wine country. Whether you’re looking t
The Willows
Seneca Lake
2
bedrooms
2
Full baths
6
guests
Welcome to Lakeside Station, where comfort, style, and stunning natural beauty come together in one unforgettable Finger Lakes vacation rental. Perfectly situated on the southeast shore of Cayuga Lake, this recently renovated vacation home captures the spirit of lakeside living with breathtaking lake views, modern amenities, and a welcoming atmosph
Lakeside Station
Cayuga Lake
5
bedrooms
3
Full baths
16
guests
Along the peaceful eastern shore of Seneca Lake, surrounded by the region’s celebrated vineyards and rolling countryside, Willow Cove offers a classic lakefront retreat that captures everything guests love about the Finger Lakes. Whether you’re planning a cozy romantic getaway for two or a laid-back retreat for a small family, this invi
Willow Cove
Seneca Lake
2
bedrooms
1
Full baths
6
guests
Nestled along the peaceful west side of Cayuga Lake, Captain’s Hideaway is the perfect escape for families, couples, and friends looking to unwind and reconnect. With 150 feet of natural lake frontage, a spacious interior designed for comfort, and a location close to the Cayuga Wine Trail, this beautiful home offers the ideal blend of relaxat
Captains Hideaway
Cayuga Lake
4
bedrooms
3
Full baths
1
Half baths
10
guests
Located along the quiet banks of the Seneca-Cayuga Canal and just minutes from the heart of Geneva, Riverside Retreat offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and lakeside charm. Set on nearly two acres of lush green property, this peaceful 3-bedroom canal-front pet-friendly home with space for up to 6 guests provides a true escape from the ev
Riverside Retreat
Seneca Lake
3
bedrooms
1
Full baths
6
guests
Olver Farm combines the tranquility of country living with the beauty and charm of Finger Lakes wine country. Nestled on 50 private acres on the west side of Cayuga Lake, this picturesque lakefront vacation home offers a peaceful retreat surrounded by cherry orchards, rolling hills, and endless lake views. Perfect for couples, small families, or cl
Olver Farm Guest House
Cayuga Lake
2
bedrooms
2
Full baths
4
guests
Discover lakeside living at its finest at English Lake House, a beautifully appointed Seneca Lake vacation rental located on the peaceful east side of the lake. Perfectly designed for families, couples, or groups traveling together, this spacious Finger Lakes vacation home combines comfort, privacy, and breathtaking lake views from every level. Wit
English Lakehouse
Seneca Lake
4
bedrooms
3
Full baths
10
guests
Lakeside Lookout offers the perfect blend of serene lakefront living and modern comfort for your next Finger Lakes vacation rental experience. Nestled high on the hills overlooking Seneca Lake, this private and peaceful vacation home provides stunning panoramic views of the water and sunsets that will take your breath away. Located midway between t
Lakeside Lookout
Seneca Lake
3
bedrooms
2
Full baths
9
guests
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Finger Lakes Premier Properties
All Rights Reserved.