Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals

cayuga lake rentals

Find the best Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals below. Browse all available homes & cabins for a perfect lake vacation!

You can filter by bedroom, guests, lakefront, hot tubs & more! 
We offer a wide range of options to choose from, from Cayuga Lake Rentals to Seneca Lake Rentals. 

Make sure to check our page with all available Finger Lakes Vacation Rentals and the shorter stays page.

Uncover the Charms of Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals in New York.
Cayuga Lake is a treasure trove of natural beauty, cultural landmarks, and aquatic adventures. It's a sought-after locale for Cayuga Lake vacation rentals, where the blend of relaxation and thrill is unparalleled. All of our Cayuga Lake vacation rentals have amazing views and lakefront access.


WHY CHOOSE OUR Cayuga Lake Vacation rentals?

Discover your dream Cayuga Lake vacation rental with Finger Lakes Premier Properties. From cozy cottages to luxury estates, we offer special savings and top-notch service for an unforgettable lakeside experience.



Explore Cayuga Lake's Must-See Spots

Staying in vacation rentals on Cayuga Lake, NY, isn't just about the lake views. The area boasts attractions like the Cayuga Wine Trail and the Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge, catering to wine connoisseurs and wildlife enthusiasts alike. Delve into the diverse experiences Cayuga Lake has in store.

Hang out with the Locals at Exciting Events

The Finger Lakes area is a hub of activity. There's an event for every interest, from the Ithaca Festival to boating regattas. For an in-depth list of upcoming events, visit our current events page.

Activities Galore at Cayuga Lake

Cayuga Lake is a paradise for those who crave outdoor excitement. The options are endless, whether it's paddleboarding, exploring the local farmers' markets, or enjoying a lakeside picnic. These offerings make Cayuga Lake vacation rentals a top pick for a fulfilling vacation. Discover more things to do in the area.

Discover Cayuga Lake's Distinctive Appeal

Cayuga Lake's elongated shape provides ample shoreline for water activities and is one of the best lakes to fish in. At the same time, its proximity to educational institutions like Cornell University adds a unique cultural flair. Eager to experience it all? Our largest Cayuga Lake property, Glenwood Lodge, is a beautiful colonial home with over 30 acres of untouched beauty and can sleep up to 20 people. Browse available properties in Cayuga Lake and kickstart your dream vacation now!

cayuga lake vacation rentals
Properties Available 30 properties available
Welcome to Lone Retreat Lake House, a serene Finger Lakes vacation rental nestled on the peaceful western shore of Cayuga Lake. This  luxurious lakefront vacation home offers the perfect combination of modern design, thoughtful amenities, and breathtaking natural beauty. Whether you’re visiting for a family gathering, a friend-filled esc
Lone Retreat Lake House
Lone Retreat Lake House 2
Lone Retreat Lake House 3
Lone Retreat Lake House 4
Lone Retreat Lake House 5
Prev
Next
Lone Retreat Lake House
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Guests 8 guests
The French Cottage on Cayuga Lake offers an inviting lakeside retreat that’s perfect for families, couples, and groups looking to experience the best of the Finger Lakes region. Whether you’re here for a fishing trip, to explore the stunning Taughannock Falls State Park, or simply to relax and enjoy sweeping views of Cayuga Lake, this b
The French Cottage
The French Cottage 2
The French Cottage 3
The French Cottage 4
The French Cottage 5
Prev
Next
The French Cottage
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 8 guests
Perched on the west side of Cayuga Lake, Wolffy’s House on the Hill is a warm and welcoming Finger Lakes retreat that perfectly balances comfort, convenience, and classic lakeside charm. Surrounded by breathtaking scenery and ideally located between the vibrant cities of Ithaca and Seneca Falls, this three-bedroom pet-friendly lake home is a
Wolffy's House on the Hill
Wolffy's House on the Hill 2
Wolffy's House on the Hill 3
Wolffy's House on the Hill 4
Wolffy's House on the Hill 5
Prev
Next
Wolffy's House on the Hill
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 9 guests
Nestled just north of Aurora on the serene east shore of Cayuga Lake, La Bella Vita offers an exquisite blend of luxury, comfort, and breathtaking natural beauty. This elegant colonial-style vacation home embodies the quintessential Finger Lakes experience, making it the perfect choice for upscale travelers seeking a memorable getaway filled with f
La Bella Vita
La Bella Vita 2
La Bella Vita 3
La Bella Vita 4
La Bella Vita 5
Prev
Next
La Bella Vita
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 12 guests
Welcome to My Blue Heaven, a stunning lakefront escape designed to offer a peaceful and luxurious retreat along the tranquil shores of Cayuga Lake! Whether you're planning a romantic couples retreat or a family getaway, this 3-bedroom pet-friendly Finger Lakes vacation rental with room for up to 8 guests provides the perfect setting for relaxat
My Blue Heaven
My Blue Heaven 2
My Blue Heaven 3
My Blue Heaven 4
My Blue Heaven 5
Prev
Next
My Blue Heaven
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 8 guests
Centrally located between the stunning gorges of Ithaca and the charming canal side of Seneca Falls, this cozy bungalow is nestled in a peaceful wooded clearing — the perfect setting for your next Finger Lakes vacation rental. At Bufflehead Bungalow, your time to relax and unwind has finally arrived.Step inside through the side door and immed
Bufflehead Bungalow
Bufflehead Bungalow 2
Bufflehead Bungalow 3
Bufflehead Bungalow 4
Bufflehead Bungalow 5
Prev
Next
Bufflehead Bungalow
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 6 guests
Experience lakeside luxury and comfort at A Shore Thing, a stunning Cayuga Lake vacation rental that redefines the meaning of relaxation. This spacious Finger Lakes vacation home was designed for families and groups who want the perfect balance of style, space, and serenity. With awe-inspiring lake views, generous indoor and outdoor living areas, a
A Shore Thing
A Shore Thing 2
A Shore Thing 3
A Shore Thing 4
A Shore Thing 5
Prev
Next
A Shore Thing
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 10 guests
Tucked among the trees and just minutes from downtown Seneca Falls, Easy Street Getaway offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. Designed in the classic Adirondack style, this inviting 3-bedroom vacation rental with space for up to 8 guests is ideal for families, couples, or friends seekin
Easy Street Getaway
Easy Street Getaway 2
Easy Street Getaway 3
Easy Street Getaway 4
Easy Street Getaway 5
Prev
Next
Easy Street Getaway
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 8 guests
Nestled just minutes from downtown Seneca Falls, Lotta Leisure is a cozy Cayuga Lake vacation home that lives up to its name. This inviting Finger Lakes vacation rental blends classic lakeside charm with modern comfort, offering families, couples, and small groups a peaceful escape along one of the region’s most beautiful stretches of shoreli
Lotta Leisure
Lotta Leisure 2
Lotta Leisure 3
Lotta Leisure 4
Lotta Leisure 5
Prev
Next
Lotta Leisure
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Half Bathrooms 1 Half baths
Guests 6 guests
Welcome to Cayuga Sunshine, a beautiful lakefront retreat that perfectly captures the charm, comfort, and natural beauty of the Finger Lakes region. Nestled on the east side of Cayuga Lake near the picturesque village of Aurora, this inviting three-bedroom vacation home with space for up to six guests offers a peaceful setting for families, couples
Cayuga Sunshine
Cayuga Sunshine 2
Cayuga Sunshine 3
Cayuga Sunshine 4
Cayuga Sunshine 5
Prev
Next
Cayuga Sunshine
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 3 Full baths
Guests 6 guests
Olver Farm Cottage welcomes you to experience a true Finger Lakes dream vacation. Nestled just steps from the pristine shores of Cayuga Lake, this newer lake home beautifully blends classic farm charm with modern elegance. Located midway between Ithaca and Seneca Falls, this vacation home offers the perfect home base to explore the best of the Fing
Olver Farm Cottage
Olver Farm Cottage 2
Olver Farm Cottage 3
Olver Farm Cottage 4
Olver Farm Cottage 5
Prev
Next
Olver Farm Cottage
Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 2 Full baths
Guests 4 guests
Welcome to Lakeview Cottage, a charming two-bedroom Finger Lakes vacation rental nestled on the northeast side of Cayuga Lake. Offering the perfect blend of cozy comfort and stunning lake views, this beautiful vacation home is ideally located midway between the historic towns of Seneca Falls and Aurora. Whether you’re attending a Wells Colleg
Lakeview Cottage
Lakeview Cottage 2
Lakeview Cottage 3
Lakeview Cottage 4
Lakeview Cottage 5
Prev
Next
Lakeview Cottage
Cayuga Lake Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Full Bathrooms 1 Full baths
Guests 6 guests

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree

Copyright © 2026 • Finger Lakes Premier Properties

All Rights Reserved.